The current TOO blog by Kevin MacDonald addresses Alexandr Solzhenitsyn’s Chapter 19 of Solzhenitsyn’s book on Jews and Russians, 200 Years Together. The main point is that:
The decade of the 1930s was tragic almost beyond description. . . . However, the suffering of Jews pales in comparison to the suffering of the Ukrainian and Russian farmers undergoing forced collectivization. Moreover, Jews were never targeted as Jews, and in general Jews remained vastly overrepresented in elite positions throughout the period, even after the purges.
MacDonald notes that “Solzhenitsyn emphasizes the culpability of the West.” In particular, we have this damning point:
In 1932–33, in Russia and Ukraine —on the very outskirts of Europe, five to six million people died from hunger! And the free press of the free world maintained utter silence… And even if we take into account the extreme Leftist bias of the contemporary Western press and its devotion to the socialist “experiment” in the USSR, it is still impossible not to be amazed at the degree to which they could go to be blind and insensitive to the sufferings of even tens of millions of fellow humans.
One powerful clue we have to this twisted mystery is the effort even now to grotesquely turn the genocide of Ukrainians in the 1930s into a story of the victims themselves slaughtering the actual murderers. In a review of a new book, Professor David O’Connell, writing in Culture Wars, finds that canny efforts by those in the Jewish community have again succeeded in getting a Catholic spokesman to do the propaganda bidding of the Jews.
In this case, O’Donnell finds that the Catholic “puppet” in question is one Fr. Patrick Desbois, an obscure French priest. Fr. Desbois penned the new book The Holocaust by Bullets: A Priest’s Journey to Uncover the Truth Behind the Murder of 1.5 Million Jews. Though “unannounced, unexpected, and lacking any expertise in the history, culture or language of the Ukraine, a French priest, Fr. Patrick Desbois, suddenly emerged in 2004 in various Jewish media outlets as a man who had made a new, breathtaking, historical discovery about that nation!”
To wit, he claims that “the Ukrainians gunned down about two million Jews in 1941–42 by shooting them in the back of the head.” O’Connell considers this absurd. What is happening, he argues, is that Jews seeking to advance the Holocaust campaign (and to hide the crimes of Soviet Jewry) have once again gone trolling for a “useful idiot” to mouth their own message.
O’Connell believes that Desbois tired of his parochial seminary duties and developed “an urge to travel, make some money, and see his name appear in the Zionist media.” Then, while visiting the Ukraine, “his Jewish handlers informed him that about 2,000,000 Jews had been killed there in 1941–42, even though not one grave of any Jewish victim had ever been marked.”
Furthermore, O’Connell asks, how can Desbois carry out his task of finding and marking Jewish graves, “especially when he cannot speak the local language and has no expert knowledge of either the history or geography of that country?” Well, testimony of very, very old locals—allegedly cross-checked with Soviet archives at the Holocaust Museum in Washington, D.C.—verifies it.
“But then, just to make sure, Desbois digs up the bodies, right? Wrong. First of all, there is no proof that Desbois has ever located the remains of even one dead Jew. But even if he were to do so, he would not dig up any remains because the rabbis who pull his strings have decreed that he would be committing a sin if he were to do so.” How convenient.
Why this effort to add up to two million new Jewish victims to the body count, and why now? French Jewish organizations, O’Connell believes,
did so because, since the breakup of the Soviet Union, the Ukrainian people have lamented, and tried to tell the world about, their own holocaust, which they call the “Holodomor.” The word refers to Stalin’s program, begun in 1932, of imposing systematic starvation on the Ukrainians because of their resistance to his imposition of collective farming. The man Stalin appointed to lead that effort, which culminated in the extermination of 7 million people, or about 25 percent of the Ukrainian population at the time, was a bloodthirsty Jewish racist and fanatic named Lazar Kaganovitch. In addition, most, if not all, of his key underlings were also Jewish.
This, of course, squares with the testimony provided us by Solzhenitsyn. O’Connell’s conclusion mirrors that of MacDonald considering Solzhenitsyn. O’Connell writes:
But, in the final analysis, the book’s true purpose is ultimately to enable the Jewish media barons to report on “the Holocaust” as if it were something that happened yesterday, to continue to divide and confuse Catholics by showing them that one of their very own, a priest consecrated to preach Christ, prefers instead to preach the secular Jewish religion of the “6,000,000” while also discrediting the Ukrainian people and their sufferings at the hands of the Jewish fanatics who served Stalin.
One point I would like to see expanded is O’Connell’s statement that:
Once the Jews had discovered him, the collaborationist French bishops made sure he moved up the ecclesiastical ladder. In 1992, he officially began his career as someone who specializes in “dialogue” with the Jews on the diocesan level, when he was appointed as Secretary for Jewish Relations by Cardinal Albert Decourtray of Lyon. He was promoted in 1999, gaining national recognition in the process, when he was appointed as Secretary of the French Bishops’ Committee for Relations with Judaism. Finally, in 2004, the French hierarchy handed him over completely to his Jewish benefactors, and the latter took full control of him.
My question is: What is the mechanism of Jewish control over the French bishops in particular and top-level Catholic clergy more generally? O’Connell offers a tantalizing hint when he writes about the Catholics who praised the book: “These Catholics, overzealous to be sure in their desire to placate the powerful Jewish abusers with whom they ‘dialogue’ . . .”
Perhaps O’Connell will someday delve into that story. For now, he reports, Desbois’s charade continues. “Desbois has been promoted yet again; … he now travels as a member of Pope Benedict XVI’s entourage when the latter engages in ‘dialogue’ with certain Jewish individuals or groups.”
This is an important story, for it instructs us in how Jews can consign their own murderous behavior to a trip down the memory hole, all the while blaming their victims for atrocities against Jews. This kind of projection of genocide needs to be exposed.
Facing the Future as a Minority
I think if you took a survey almost nobody would know who Lazar Kaganovich is, let alone his role in the systematic destruction of millions of Ukrainians. Meanwhile, EVERYBODY knows ALL of the Nazi Henchmen even down to the lowest ranks. It’s pretty amazing exercise in Jewish media control that a man responsible for the deaths of five to six million people is still shrouded in anonymity.
Glen, don’t forget Yagoda or the twenty-five thousanders, the party riff raff who descended upon Ukrainians to murder them and steal their property. Everywhere the Jews go they bring famine and murder.
Oh…and what a whore that Fr. Patrick Desbois is!
During 1929-33 the predominantly Jewish enforcers/supporters of Judeo-bolshevism variously killed the entire white, Christian, Ukrainian rural and urban middle class: c. 8-10 million men, women, and children. During 1941-42, Nazi-recruited Ukrainian police units, in the course of a ferocious war against communist partisans, rounded up and shot c. 1 million Jews in the Ukraine. What goes around, comes around; and I am equally sure that the lieing, on all sides of the issue, will continue.
Yes, but while the former are exonerated, certain interests want us never to forget how culpable the Ukrainians were (and apparently always will be)…. that is why John Demjanuk is in a prison cell in Germany. Look at the poor guy’s Wikipedia page.
I suspect that the Catholic Church is also taking an opportunity to bloody the nose of the Orthodox in Ukraine, too. In Ukraine, the relationship between the churches still is not good and there are lingering property disputes, as well as a more general dispute over which church is property the guardian of Ukrainian culture.
I’m surprised that there hasn’t been more discussion of the shameful trial of John Demjanuk here.
Despite denying him many basic rights (such as putting him in double jeopardy, denying him the right to confront his accusers), and despite using blatant KGB disinformation (from the 1980′s) against him, they haven’t proven any crimes.
It seems that the only thing that has been proved against him is that he was a fascist sympathizer. No one has the balls to say that for someone who grew up in Ukraine, as Demjanuk did, and saw the massacre and starvation of his countrymen, whatever the Nazis were doing probably wouldn’t have been too shocking. At the very least one should be able to say that people like him could have very well been motivated to collaborate with the fascists by the entirely righteous desire to overthrow or remove Stalin, not because they were genocidal.
Agree with all the points you make. But, thanks to the internet, Jews are being a little LESS exonerated than they were before.
Interesting that the Holodomor it is now officially recognized as a ‘Crime against Humanity’ in the EU -
*KMac should do a seperate article just on that atrocious sub-human excuse for a man Walter Duranty — who alone was almost single-handedly responsible for America and the Roosevelt administration granting the criminal and illegitimate Soviet regime official recognition — right as Holodomor was raging!
Mr. Connelly: You wrote, “My question is: What is the mechanism of Jewish control over the French bishops in particular and top-level Catholic clergy more generally?”
Your question lacks a short answer, as I’m sure you already suspect. To make a start at an answer, you need to have a look at two books of moderate length by a long-deceased Frenchman called Léon de Poncins: Judaism and the Vatican (1967) and Freemasonry and the Vatican (1968). Both of these books—English translations of French originals, of course—may still be found in paperback reprint editions, albeit with some small difficulty. If you read French, you might to your profit look for a copy of a book Poncins wrote some thirty-five years earlier, Les Juifs maîtres du monde.
Poncins documents, primarily from Jewish sources, the centuries-long program of infiltration of the clergy and the hierarchy by Marrano Jews. (Of course, he was not the first to tell this tale, but most of the scholarly nineteenth-century studies of Jewish conspiracies written in the five main western European languages have effectively sunk without trace. Some have simply been pulped by everybody’s favorite proponents of absolute freedom of speech; you know, the same nice folks who want to see David Irving, Ernst Zündel, and Richard Williamson in prison cells and Kevin MacDonald flipping quarter pounders at McDonald’s.) To say the Jews were playing a very long game is nothing less than the plain truth. Were it not for the fact that I am, as Poncins was, a Traditional Catholic, I would not hold out even a glimmer of a hope for the future restoration of the Church and the eventual purging of its sworn enemies from its ranks.
Pierre,
You might find this highly uplifting -
So when Rabbi Kryger took command of the lectern at Notre Dame to commit the sacrilege of addressing the Christian faithful on the subject of Moses and the Law, a contingent of young traditional French Catholics “arose as one body and with one voice recited the Apostles Creed and the Rosary aloud in the cathedral.”
Michael Hoffman, “Traditional French Catholics Disrupt Rabbi’s Sermon at Notre Dame”, Wed 24, 2010. Revisionist Review Blogspot.
French television ultimately cut the transmission and Church officials attempted to stifle and drown out the voice of the Roman Catholic Faithful with the organ and choir — but the Remnant did not relent — but luckily you can still view this blessed event in the history of the true Church and witness one of the Remnant’s greatest acts in defiance for God -
http://www.gloria.tv/?media=61422
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lx-ga2jnzCA&feature=player_embedded
Viva le France!
The archbishop of paris is jewish…why cant this other priest be a jew as well? the whole thing with judaism and catholicism stinks anyway
Reality Check – AMAZING video! I had no idea. Zounds. I need to brush up on my French. I was trying to read the comments on the video. I was only picking out a few bits and pieces. Bless the Remnants!
True extent of Ukraine famine revealed in British journalist’s diaries – Times Online
Here is a link to a National Review article on Walter Duranty and the New York Times suppression of news about the forced starvation of millions of Ukrainians.
http://old.nationalreview.com/stuttaford/stuttaford200311240920.asp
Athanasius said…
I’m surprised that there hasn’t been more discussion of the shameful trial of John Demjanuk here.
Despite denying him many basic rights (such as putting him in double jeopardy, denying him the right to confront his accusers), and despite using blatant KGB disinformation (from the 1980′s) against him, they haven’t proven any crimes.
–
Well, at least Pat Buchanan courageously stood up for Demjanuk and the utterly evil treatment he received in the hands of the modern-day ‘Soviet’ -
“The spirit behind this un-American persecution has never been that of justice tempered by mercy. It is the same satanic brew of hate and revenge that drove another innocent Man up Calvary that first Good Friday 2,000 years ago.”
VDARE.com: 04/13/09 – “John Demanjuk And The True Haters”
http://vdare.com/buchanan/090413_true_haters.htm
One also can notice that the root of the name Kaganovich is shared by our new Bolshevik Supreme Court Jewess Elana Kagan
Looks like we are rapidly becoming a cross between Weimar Germany and Bolshevik Soviet Union.
No one even knows dead Jew Richard Holbrooke’s real name. “Holbrooke’s” father a Russian Jew had as an adult wandered into the United States—he had changed his name to “Holbrooke” while still in Europe.
Projection. The holocaust was itself a projection, an inner desire to rid the world of non-Jews, becomes the illusion of Jewish extermination camps.
Their control is almost complete…the “Holocaust” is their ace in the hole.
Expose it and watch their house of cards fall.
Revisionist
Victims of the New Inquistion
The Hoax of the Twentieth
Century
The Rudolf Report
By the way, Khrushchev was a Ukrainian who assisted in the collectivization of the Ukraine. I hear they reserved a special place in hell just for him. I believe Robert Conquest pointed
out the locust like swarm of Russian coffee house layabouts– 25 thousand–that descended upon the hapless Ukrainians. They murdered and raped them, stole their property and especially their food. The Jewish NYT made sure no one ever heard about them.
As regards Kaganovich and his part in the genocidal Holodomor, it is interesting, and ironic, that the king of the Khazars was known as a ‘Kagan’. Furthermore, the capital of Khazaria was called Sarkel, and was located near the Don River in the present eastern Ukraine. Believe it or not, there is a Jewish/Khazar website that covers their history, and has published a book on the subject; see the Khazar website @:
http://www.khazaria.com/
Mr. Pierre de Craon,
Thank you for the insightful comments on the Vatican. It sounds like what E. Michael Jones insinuates in his excellent book “The Jewish Revolutionary Spirit.” (I reviewed it for the Summer 2010 issue of The Occidental Quarterly–hope all will subscribe.)
In Russia I’ve read estimates that range from 60 million to over 100 million White Russians were murdered since 1917. In Ukraine from 6 to 8 million white middle class and Kulak farmers were exterminated just in the years 1932 – 33.
After the war eastern europe was handed over to jewish soviet control.
Think about what life was like for any whites remaining and what must have been strong pressure to intermarry in an attempt to survive.
Why does anyone think there are any real white people (not part jew) left in the countries that were under Jewish Soviet control. The jews had plenty of time to wipe out all white christians and pollute the white gene pool with Edomite blood.
Yet miraculously we’re told of a revival of Orthodox Christianity and white nationalism in Russia and former soviet block countries.
Say what you will about the Russians, but it took tremendous vigor to create an empire stretching from Helsinki to Juneau and to defeat the Turks, Tatars, Persians, and Caucasian tribes along the way.
Even Stalin knew this, and he knew that the only way he would win the war was to tap into this feeling. That is why he re-legalized the Orthodox Church, allowed the election of a new Patriarch, and suppressed at least the craziest propaganda that the political commissars were putting out (“Alexander Nevsky” instead of “Circus”)
What is the evidence that all these people died? How are the figures determined? I ask only because I am aware that at times such figures are a farce.
Athanasius says: “it took tremendous vigor to create an empire stretching from Helsinki to Juneau”
Juneau? Try Ft.Ross California! The Russian settlement there lasted from 1812 to 1841.
True. It was contested with the Spanish so I didn’t put that!
The trouble with Ukraine natives is that they have no guts of their own. They like to be told what to do as if they were children.
One example was a football match I went to see some 4 years a go. During my time in the football stadium, I saw elderly Americans groping and molesting young Ukrainian women in front of so many supposedly testosterone filled young men. The young men did not even look at the American men with disgust, but continued to cheer on their team as if they couldn’t be bothered.
If Ukrainians are not bothered, who will help them?
Kratos writes:
“I saw elderly Americans groping and molesting young Ukrainian women”
LOLWUT!???! A statement like that screams for more detail.
Wasn’t the holocaust an essential part of the post war denazification programme (post Tehran Conference Dec 1943 and consistent with The Morgenthua Plan)? Wasn’t it used by the Western allies to re-establish Liberatrain free-market democracy (economic anarchism) in Germany (and subsequently build the Europe Project) as an esssential butress against the Weswards spread of Stalinist Socialism in One Country (and Pan Artabism in the Middle East)?
Seen as a pro Libertarian free-market PsyOps tool (like Human Rights legaislation), with Jews as major economic and social beneficiaries, Western Governments are hardly likely to let it be undermined, are they? I suggest, at root, it’s as simple as that. It can be elaborated to explain a lot that is now wrong of course.
People ask whether the Pope is a Catholic. It is assumed to be a rhetorical question. Is the answer quite as obvious as people assume? I think not. Another question about bears has an answer too. Who feeds us these little gems? The people who control the media and manufacture our culture are prime candidates.
Speaking of the jewish “holocaust”, why would Germany go through all the trouble of transportation (logistics), housing and camp organization (government) if a “holocaust” was the intended result. It seems that most of the problems in the camps were due to wartime conditions, lack of proper sanitation, (typhus, etc.). I have been researching the so-called jewish “holocaust” for many years; most of what is spouted as “holocaust” orthodoxy cannot withstand critical analysis and scrutiny. Many countries have put ANY discussion of (ideas contrary to) “holocaust” orthodoxy off limits and subject to criminal prosecution. What are the jews afraid of?? Even the “six million” figure doesn’t add up. In my humble opinion, the jewish “holocaust” is a hoax that was generated to soften up us gentiles for a (stolen) “jewish homeland” (israel). In addition, US foreign policy has been hijacked by hardcore dual-nationality zionists and is preparng us for our next military “adventure” (iran). Don’t believe me?? Check out who’s who in MY American government; you will not like what you see. What used to be considered “fringe” thinking by various “white supremacist” groups has come to fruition. At the present, we have a “zionist occupation government”. We are in the midst of jewish supremacist movement that dictates the direction MY country is taking. George Bush’s “new world order has taken hold. Our direction is determined by the “powers that be” in tel aviv and jerusalem.
Most people are unaware of the “jewish boycotts” of Germany in the 1930′s. The jewish boycotts of German goods and services was written about in the “Jerusalem Post” and was considered a (economic) “war” on Germany. (You can still read the articles on-line today).
It is fact that zionists were looking for ways to “encourage” jews to emigrate to what was then known as Palestine. Most German jews lived comfortable lives and had no desire to emigrate. Being of the upper strata of German society, jews were firmly in control of banks, news media, entertainment and other businesses and had no desire to leave all that behind. The marginalization of jewish “society” was a result of agitation by various (jewish-led and inspired) groups (communists, socialists, anarchists), the devaluation of German currency by banks, and in general, social unrest. The zionists used the (intended) marginalization to their benefit. Zionists figured that if they made life difficult for German jews, emigration would be looked at as a “solution”. In fact, influential zionists collaborated with the Nazi government to “help” jews emigrate. For more on this subject read “51 Questions (And Answers), Jewish Collaboration With The Nazis” by author Lenni Brenner