Ron Unz in the New York Times

In my article on Ron Unz’s  “The Myth of American Meritocracy” I noted that it did not get much buzz in the above ground media. But Unz managed to get a brief comment in the New York Times “Room for Debate” feature (“Fears of an Asian Quota in the Ivy League“).  Unz uses some of the data from his article to make the case that indeed discrimination is involved (“Statistics indicate an Ivy League Asian Quota“).

The only noteworthy comment was by Jeff Neal, director of university communications for the faculty of arts and sciences at Harvard. Neal attempts to combat the weight of statistics by assurances that admission is based on reviews that are “individualized and holistic.” In other words, they are completely opaque, so they can do what they want. And the result is a very large underrepresentation of Asians and the much larger underrepresentation of non-Jewish Whites controlled for academic achievement.

Advertisement

Given the debate topic, I guess it’s not surprising that the massive Jewish overrepresentation compared to Whites is not considered. But then one wonders why this isn’t considered to be a valid topic for the “Room for Debate” forum. In the debate on Asian quotas, S. B. Woo was something of an official Asian spokesman, representing the 80-20 National Asian American Educational Foundation. Not surprisingly, he concluded that it was obvious Asians were being discriminated against. It would be easy to find Jews to defend Jews, but the Times would doubtless shrink from the very idea that there could be a spokesperson for the interests of non-Jewish Whites.

Unz’s article was also mentioned in the NYTimes by David Brooks who announced that it was a winner of a Sidney Award for the best magazine articles on 2012. Brooks emphasizes the theme of Asian quotas, but also notes that

Unz’s other big point is that Jews are vastly overrepresented at elite universities and that Jewish achievement has collapsed. In the 1970s, for example, 40 percent of top scorers in the Math Olympiad had Jewish names. Now 2.5 percent do. The fanatical generations of immigrant strivers have been replaced by a more comfortable generation of preprofessionals, he implies.

Well, there’s another big point in Unz’s article—that non-Jewish Whites are vastly underrepresented compared to Jews. Indeed, compared to Jews, non-Jewish Whites are represented at 1/15th of the level they would be in a meritocratic system. And Brooks never even attempts to fathom why the comfortable generation of preprofessionals continues to be so vastly overrepresented given their unstellar academic records.

Another big point that is missing from Brooks’ comment is that the fact that Jews are predominant in the higher reaches of the administration of Ivy League universities is doubtless part of the reason for the favoritism toward Jews in university admissions.

But, given Neal’s assurances, I am absolutely certain that the holistic and individualized system in place at Harvard is entirely fair. Neal proudly notes that Harvard has submitted a brief supporting holistic admissions criteria in the Fisher vs. University of Texas case that is currently before the Supreme Court. On the basis of Unz’s data, it’s apparent that the holistic admissions process is a way for elite universities to simultaneously admit Blacks, Latinos and Jews at much higher rates than they would on the basis of academic qualifications, while discriminating against Asians and non-Jewish Whites. Indeed, the left side of the following figure shows that on the basis of total college-age population, non-Jewish Whites are underrepresented compared to Blacks and Latinos at Harvard and Yale as well as several other elite universities. The right side of the figure shows that non-Jewish White underrepresentation is far more glaring when one includes only high ability students.

eliteenrollment-large

The displacement of White elites is well underway. There are many mechanisms for this, but clearly the use of holistic admissions to elite universities is an important one.

Share:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

64 Comments to "Ron Unz in the New York Times"

  1. Frank Edwin Stone's Gravatar Frank Edwin Stone
    January 1, 2013 - 2:31 am | Permalink

    @Catiline: You guys should remember that this is a perfect world, after all: the problem will solve itself once word gets out about the real state of affairs at Ivy League admissions.

    The Ivy League will self destruct, will devalue itself.
    What will take its place are real institutions of learning, like CalTech and MIT. Pure meritocracy, no Politically Correct , Multi-Kulti rubbish.

  2. Frank Edwin Stone's Gravatar Frank Edwin Stone
    January 1, 2013 - 2:23 am | Permalink

    @Franklin Ryckaert: That exact thing had been tried in Hungary in the 1920s in University admissions. It was called numerus clausus, if I recall correctly. It restricted the number of admissions of Jewish students to their percentage of the population as a whole.

  3. Frank Edwin Stone's Gravatar Frank Edwin Stone
    January 1, 2013 - 2:17 am | Permalink

    @sanjay: Sailer is not a Jew or crypto-Jew. Do not invent things out of thin air.

    What proof do you have about Sailer being of Jewish origin?

  4. Joe McCarthy's Gravatar Joe McCarthy
    December 29, 2012 - 11:56 am | Permalink

    Where’s Matt Heimbach and his White Student Union?

    They need to get on this case immediately! Create a firestorm.

    Seriously though, I heard someone make a comment about this generation of Jews being spoiled, lazy, preprofessionals.

    Well, this generation of whites is not too different.

    The only difference is that this generation of whites is really the one getting screwed by this debt economy and institutional discrimination.

    Frankly, I am just happy that this little pro-white ghetto exists where I can escape the outside world of fantasy and come into reality.

    As for my brethren, let them suffer.

    Once they realize that the liberal democracy run on debt is not really this cushy world that privileges them they will do something.

    And if they don’t, then they deserve whatever they get.

  5. Biff Preston's Gravatar Biff Preston
    December 28, 2012 - 6:59 pm | Permalink

    With regards to Daniel Luzer I could not find a definite Jewish connection but I did find a bit of information.

    He certainly is aware of Jewish interests as evidenced by the following articles. I suspect that he might just be a red diaper baby, much like Amy Biehl.

    http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/college_guide/blog/college_students_learning_yidd.php

    http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/college_guide/blog/new_jews.php

    http://www.cjr.org/the_kicker/stung_out.php

    http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/college_guide/blog/yale_ends_antisemitism_study_p.php

    http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/college_guide/blog/berkeley_students_vote_to_dive_1.php

    I found the following from a fairly recent obituary, which shows a listing of some of his family members. I searched on each one and there were no maiden names or anything else that would indicate Jewish ancestry.

    Heres an obituary entry for his late Paternal grandmother Golda

    Luzer, Golda F.
    June 23, 2005, wife of the late Adolph F. Luzer; beloved mother of David C.
    (Patricia) and Richard J. (Nancy) Luzer; grandmother of Ellen M. (Warren)
    Krueger, Mary E. , Daniel E. and Matthew R. Luzer; great-grandmother of
    William M. and Jack D. Krueger. Friends may call Sunday 4-7 at the DENGLER &
    ROBERTS FUNERAL HOME, 8630 Transit Rd., E. Amherst (1 mile north of Maple
    Rd.), where prayers will be offered Monday at 9 AM followed by a Mass of
    Christian Burial from St. Gregory The Great Church at 9:30 AM.

    http://files.usgwarchives.net/ny/erie/obits/bn-dn/2005/jun/bn-dn25jun2005.txt

    I found an interesting article while searching for Daniel Luzer’s Jewish ancestry, written by a David Brooks. In the article he openly admits that there is much truth to the Jewish takeover of elite positions in American society and in our elite universities.

    http://www.nytimes.com/2005/11/06/books/review/06brooks.html?_r=0

  6. Biff Preston's Gravatar Biff Preston
    December 28, 2012 - 4:31 pm | Permalink

    It’s where they factor things like “cultural experiences”, geography and race into the admissions equation. It’s a fancy sounding way of favoring non-whites. I never liked George Bush’s so called “affirmative enrollment” but it’s obvious that they are going to scrap that in favor of the “holistic” approach. Affirmative enrollment discriminates against people like me, who are non- traditional students, which I currently am, in favor of top percentile graduating high school seniors, despite how well I might do academically.

  7. Peter J's Gravatar Peter J
    December 28, 2012 - 4:20 pm | Permalink

    Here’s a bit more on Daniel Luzer

    http://www.washingtonmonthly.com/college_guide/blog/new_jews.php

    He’s certainly smug and subversive…

  8. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 28, 2012 - 2:00 am | Permalink

    Richard have a great New Year and on into 2013. Peace.

  9. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 28, 2012 - 1:05 am | Permalink

    @91: Thank you, for supporting my contentions, by citing very specific references concerning the massive influx of Mexicans and the reasons why they are allowed to simply flood in. We have been lied to for years and are still being lied to.

  10. 91's Gravatar 91
    December 28, 2012 - 12:33 am | Permalink

    @sanjay:
    Marx, Freud were not just anti Christian, they were anti human.

  11. 91's Gravatar 91
    December 28, 2012 - 12:31 am | Permalink

    Obama is recruiting in Mexico. His people met 10x? 15x
    to get more mexicans here, on EBT.
    Ads are in Spanish for EBT.
    I hear ads on the radio for ‘benefits’.
    Here : endoftheamericandream.com
    Government Website For Immigrants: Come To America And Take Advantage Of Our Free Stuff

    dailycaller:

    The DHS page offers links to government websites that explain how to access benefits including food stamps, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), Medicaid, Medicare, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) and the “official website with information on all available federal benefit programs,” with a nonworking link to Benefits.gov.

    WelcometoUSA.gov also boasts to immigrants that “[f]ree public education for children is one reason many immigrants come to the United States.”

    Though the website appears to adve

    Read more: http://dailycaller.com/2012/11/18/homeland-security-promotes-welfare-to-new-immigrants-in-government-welcome-materials/#ixzz2GK0ac4E8

  12. Richard's Gravatar Richard
    December 27, 2012 - 11:13 pm | Permalink

    “Yes, nowadays about the only people that make sense are the folks on forums like this.”

    I remember writing something similar.

    If you or anyone else reading this ever feel any amount of tension in your body, try placing your hand (especially your palm) over your navel (also known as the belly button).

    Doing this brings peace to the body and mind.

    I discovered this technique sort of by accident last week, and then I remembered reading it somewhere several years ago. (So it’s not really my discovery, of course.)

    I’ve done it frequently over the past week, and it works every time. So I want to share it with others in case it helps. (And for me, it really does it help. An example of how a “little” thing is actually a big thing.)

    Just to be clear, I do it with my shirt on. I mean, my hand doesn’t touch the bare skin of my stomach. It just gently covers my navel area, which is covered by a shirt.

  13. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 27, 2012 - 10:37 pm | Permalink

    @Richard: Now it’s your emotions I can feel. Isn’t it all plain sick and dementetd? On the other hand Richard, the left needs to be asked, why they no longer care about the “white working stiff”, (they clearly don’t), unions whose ancestors those white working stiffs fought for and often got killed for, why the left allows outsourcing and insourcing of Americans jobs, why the left and its ACLU is always taking the sides of foreign nationals illegaly in this country, and why they feel that whites, who are already stretched with their finances should have to pay for the benefits of those “minorities”,(anyone that isn’t white and came to the U.S. yesterday). Why does the left allow the importation of a million people a year, thus further straining the job prospects of those minorities they claim to care about. And why, for instance, don’t they go to their buddies in Hollywood, that are all on board with the lefts anti-white program, and ask the “Movie Stars”, Directors and the rest of the millionaires there, why they won’t chip in to help the “minorities”? I noticed that when Bush Jr. was President, the movie stars all got tax breaks that saved them more of their millions, but they didn’t distribute that money they saved to the “minorities” they support. Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm… But then again, they also said, Barbara Streisand and Co. that they were going to leave the U.S. because of Bush Jr. but they didn’t. Even after getting his tax breaks. Yes, nowadays about the only people that make sense are the folks on forums like this.

  14. Richard's Gravatar Richard
    December 27, 2012 - 8:02 pm | Permalink

    @Bobby:

    Sometimes I feel the emotions that you express in your comments. What gets to me is the sense of injustice. That’s one of the worst feelings in this world.

    For example, I was reading an article on a liberal site a short while ago, and it mentioned that one of the reasons why non-Whites need more (free) internet access is so that they can research government benefits.

    That’s almost like saying they need more government benefits (in the form of free or cheap internet access) in order to get more government benefits.

    (Unless I misunderstood the author’s point…)

    Actually I don’t read much news these days. And a part of me regrets reading that article.

  15. Alice Teller's Gravatar Alice Teller
    December 27, 2012 - 6:36 pm | Permalink

    @Bobby:
    Not a rant at all. Preach brother! You may not realize that you are telling a story which is censored in the press. Can I get a witness?

    It is long past time for an amicable divorce. As always it will be unpleasant, but we may as well got to it. The is no moral reasoning abroad in the world today by which we can be denied with any justice or credibility. The more we talk about it, the more that will become clear to all. Once the issue arises in a serious way it will become the obvious and inevitable answer.

  16. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 27, 2012 - 5:57 pm | Permalink

    @Bobby: I’m starting to believe people like Luke on the question of ethno states. This system cannot be fixed, patched up, or turned around in any way that will bring it back to a state of normalcy. The reason why, which anyone should see by now, is because it’s all planned by the elite who are following an agenda that isn’t American but that is International. It’s a mistake to think that International philosophy puts citizens of any state, LAST. It doesn’t believe in citizens, PERIOD!!

  17. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 27, 2012 - 5:51 pm | Permalink

    @Alice Teller: Alice, it’s beyond weird what goes on in California. Every store, government office, park, beach, had, for some crazy reason, signs in Spanish. This wasn’t so a mere twenty-five years ago. Yet California has a few million Asians, tens of thousands of Indians from India, etc. How come the signs are only in Spanish, is something I wondered about for years. I finally concluded that it’s simply part of instituting the North American Union, (NAU), (The North American Free Trade Agreement, (NAFTA), and all of the other traitorous deals our traitorous Congress and Senate have done behind the backs of American citizens. There can’t be any other reason for the fanatical implimentation of all things “hispanic”,etc. There is no effective border control, any Senator or Congresman who claims it is lying. There are no laws against illegal aliens in California that hold them accountable for anything short of murder, and even then, they just take off to Mexico. If they are then caught in Mexico, the U.S. must promise Mexico not to impliment the death penalty against them, which is apparently only reserved for American citizens, that people like George Bush carried out enthusiastically. Excuse my rant, Alice and others, but truth be told, I haven’t even begun to describe the insanity in California that is spreading across the Southwest and will arrive at every state in the U.S. BY DESIGN. BY DESIGN OF THE MANY, MANY, TRAITORS WE HAVE IN THIS NATION.

  18. Alice Teller's Gravatar Alice Teller
    December 27, 2012 - 5:07 pm | Permalink

    @Bobby:
    I find your dispatches from California invaluable, and I thank all here who continue the clarion call of danger ahead, it may be that you live among a special subset of whites. In American, we are all descended from a subset of people who were willing to cut all ties with home and family to begin anew. We have always been willing to move for any number of reasons. The most adventurous among us made it all the way to California. Many of those were quick to move out again when the state began to decline. Twenty years ago I heard people from Idaho talk about the mass inflow of Californians.

    If we still have the right stuff may well be decided by the gun control issue. The absurdly moralistic and condescending tone and approach both of the liberals in general and the media in particular, has been over the top. We live in interesting times.

  19. December 27, 2012 - 4:57 pm | Permalink

    @Bobby:
    crypto-jews will try to infect any white movement from inside. IMO, crypto-jews are million times more lethal than strongly identified jews.

    Boas, Marx, Freud may have come up with great ideas, but without crypto-jews inside the banking system and media, they would be just barking dogs. mass indoctrination is only possible in its early stages when whites believe white elite (a large percentage of whom could be cryptos).

  20. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 27, 2012 - 4:08 pm | Permalink

    @Luke: Luke, at first I had my doubts about the ethno state idea. But I thought about what I wrote to Franklin again, and now I’m not so sure. For all kinds of reasons, whites will never, ever, fight for their rights in this system, through the courts or otherwise. They’ve had years and years of abuse and the time that they could have made a sound, a squeak, shall we say. But they have not. So those whites that are serioius enough to fight for a European-American ethno state should do so, and go full speed ahead. Afterall, it’s always a small minority of people that have the guts to form any movement that will be challenged by the status quo, the moment it sees things getting serious.

  21. December 27, 2012 - 3:33 pm | Permalink

    @Mickey Meadows:
    spectrum of realism shifts with time. look at china. so weak until 70s. look at it today, a world power.

    We should keep developing our capabilites, physical fitness, sexual abstinence, large families, a house, mastery of skilled trade, mental and problem solving abilities, all these will come handy when conditions for a new white ethnostate will emerge.

    No ruling class has ruled forever. Jews will decline, they are already declining. It is upto us to build ourselves into a powerful cohesive fertile people, and recover our white heritage. everything else will follow naturally.

    We cannot save all whites. We cannot save those who have been indoctrinated beyond repair. We should wake up those who are on the margins, who are right leaning, who see that this whole evangelical, rapture, old testament game plan is to bleed and impoverish us.

    So long as we keep building ourselves as individuals, families, ethnically conscious people, our time will come.

    1200 years ago there were just 1000 people in madagascar, today there are 20 million. that is the power of fertility.

  22. Pierre de Craon's Gravatar Pierre de Craon
    December 27, 2012 - 2:13 pm | Permalink

    @me:

    Both of you gentlemen make good sense and excellent points, but combining your two comments produces a critical insight that lots of our friends and fellows simply still don’t get: it is precisely through near-complete control of the media that the Tribe “shape[s] the narrative” and thereby keeps other whites, who would join us if only they saw how they could, “marginalized, disorganized and dispirited.”

    In addition, I think that it ought to be taken for granted that everything published under Scott McConnell’s auspices or at his behest has one true purpose and no other: to restore him to the good graces of the Podhoretz family. That this aim, despite two decades’ worth of off-target shots, still governs his thoughts and actions is something I am yet to be unpersuaded of. Precisely how Unz, his story, the subsidiary characters and commenting figures and institutions, and the story’s interpretation and aftermath fit into this larger purpose is by no means clear to me or to many other observers, but I am quite confident that, no matter how the matter plays out, McConnell’s sycophancy will turn out to be at its root.

  23. Mary Thomas's Gravatar Mary Thomas
    December 27, 2012 - 11:53 am | Permalink

    The FED should be taken over and shut down. This was Ron Paul’s long term goal because he understood that this entity is the center of their power structure. This banking cartel prints money for the owner banks that behave recklessly and can do no wrong. This cartel also makes war easy, because all they have to do is print the money to make war, whereas if the people had to pay through tax increases there would likely be no war.

  24. December 27, 2012 - 11:03 am | Permalink

    @Franklin Ryckaert:
    While the idea of insisting on proportional representation sounds attractive, it is none-the-less doomed to failure. How is that insistence going to be put into place? The insistence will turn into accusations of racism. Which politician, including those with aspirations to be presidents of universities, is going to fall on his sword for it?

    I have come to the conclusion that Whites must cast off, temporarily at least, the chains of the last 300 years of our civilization and revert to real pogroms as advocated by JB Campbell. Angry White people can do enormous grievous bodily harm to the tribe. They do not fear us at this time, but they need to.

  25. Marcus's Gravatar Marcus
    December 27, 2012 - 10:06 am | Permalink

    @90404:
    What percentage of the black student body is there on athletic scholarship? And at USC?

  26. Fatboy's Gravatar Fatboy
    December 27, 2012 - 8:18 am | Permalink

    @fender: I think you guys are misconsruing Luzer’ s comment. He is saying we need to fundamentally restructure the system that gives Goldman Sachs stockholders 99% of the nation’ s wealth rather than fret over who happens to work there. This bizarre system of financial elites running the country and gutting any purposeful industry in advancement of their own ascendancy is itself a reflection of a particular sort of elite, I might say. Ivy league grads used to want to be poets: the Benets, Conrad Aiken, RD Eliot. Now they are off to bigger and better things, like defrauding the rest of us. It’ s the normal course of civilization. Read the story of Essay and Jacob.

  27. Luke's Gravatar Luke
    December 27, 2012 - 7:19 am | Permalink

    @Franklin Ryckaert: What you are proposing, Franklin – is a short term solution. However, as I explained at considerable length in my earlier essay which TOO was kind enough to feature – non-whites are not about to adopt or mimic our Aryan sense of ‘fairness’ and ‘sportsmanship’, now that they have managed to steal our nation away from White European people, post November 6th, 2012.

    Hence, we are never going to talk non-whites into going along with a proportional system such as you describe. Not in the political arena, and not in the academic arena, or in any other area of our rapidly decomposing society. The racial deck is stacked in their favor, and they intend to keep it that way.

    This is why the breakup of this nation and the subsequent creation of an exclusively White Ethnostate is priority #1 and one which will have zero non-whites inside it, and also have laws on the books which will make white race treason an offense that will result in an immediate termination of residency privileges and a permanent exile from the White Ethnostate a hard-coded, fact of law. This is the only way Whites will ever be able to get this affirmative action curse off our backs, because non-whites are never going to voluntarily give it up.

    And, as Professor MacDonald has pointed out – the Blue State crowd harbors such a deep-seated, vitriolic, simmering hatred and resentment for the Whites in the Red States, that there is really no legitimate reason for them to not be just as happy to separate themselves from us as we will be to separate ourselves from them, right?

    Let’s ratchet this idea up and get the details hammered out before the opportunity to divorce peacefully is no longer possible.

  28. Bob Roberts's Gravatar Bob Roberts
    December 27, 2012 - 6:37 am | Permalink

    Brooks is an interesting writer. He has written articles in the past in which he compares the “WASP” regime of old favorably with the present, although he doesn’t say just who the present powerholders are. Now, of all the articles he could mention in his annual “must-read” list, he puts Unz’s first and foremost. He certainly does obscure Unz’s criticism of Jews and the fact of discrimination against non-Jewish whites. Still, it seems to me that by recommending the article so highly he is signaling his coreligionists in a way. Being willing to acknowledge things that seem to go against one’s interests is a very rare trait, so I give him credit.

    In the meantime, in the same paper, I can’t help noticing that some writers drop things into their opinion pieces that would earn the highest ADL condemnation if uttered by Patrick Buchanan. Here, for example, in his Christmas Day defense of Chuck Hagel, is Thomas Friedman: “But most U.S. senators, policy makers and Jews prefer to stick their heads in the sand, because confronting Israel is so unpleasant and politically dangerous.” Did he say “politically dangerous”? My Lord, methinks I hear a canard.

  29. Mickey Meadows's Gravatar Mickey Meadows
    December 27, 2012 - 6:36 am | Permalink

    @sanjay:

    Sure, but you are all calling into the empty wilderness. Powerless.

    I’m not trying to put a downer on things, but it is actually more powerful to stand in a place of realism.

    It is from that place of realism and – via KM and others – good information and knowledge, the true fightback will take form.

    If it is to be real, it must come from that space of realism.

  30. Mickey Meadows's Gravatar Mickey Meadows
    December 27, 2012 - 6:31 am | Permalink

    @Franklin Ryckaert:

    With what power would we do this? The Jewish are now the ruling elite…and they aren’t much like the gentlemanly WASP either.
    Try going back to Georgian times and ‘demanding’ something the ruling elite don’t want to happen.

  31. December 27, 2012 - 12:00 am | Permalink

    @Richard: @Franklin Ryckaert:
    some of us have been calling for an explicit white quota for a long time. its great that so many of us think alike.

    White Quotas will strengthen white identity, give whites clear goals to advance their interests, motivate them to boost fertility, motivate them to control immigration.

    But blood tests are necessary due to very high % of crypto-jews. The Nazi method of tracing ancestry is obsolete and easily gamed by cryptos.

    DNA tests are a must to smoke out cryptos. Cryptos are the greatest cancer inside America and Europe. They are the most lethal and sinister of them all. Absolute traitors.

  32. 90404's Gravatar 90404
    December 26, 2012 - 11:57 pm | Permalink

    ‘ holistic admissions to elite universities is an important one.’
    What is holisic admissions?t

  33. 90404's Gravatar 90404
    December 26, 2012 - 11:54 pm | Permalink

    @Mary Thomas:
    Blacks are under represented in colleges.
    Asians are over represented.

    UCLA is 30% Asian? 2 ? % Black.

  34. 90404's Gravatar 90404
    December 26, 2012 - 11:51 pm | Permalink

    LUZER is a jewish first name.

    eaving the Faith: A Man Who Left His Hasidic Roots in Brooklyn …
    http://www.wnyc.org/…/leaving-faith-man-who-left-his-hasidic-roots-broo...
    Apr 17, 2011 – Oftentimes, it is a mixture of both, as in the case of Luzer Twersky. … Luzer’s story of the challenges of breaking out of the Orthodox Jewish world as I … One word of advice to Luzer please move on you took a courageous path, …
    Luzer Shulman, as a Jewish youth in hiding – Photo Archives
    digitalassets.ushmm.org/photoarchives/detail.aspx?id…search…
    Luzer Shulman, as a Jewish youth in hiding on a farm near Warsaw. … 1945, she worked in an electronics factory under the false name, Sophie Zajaczkowska.

  35. Richard's Gravatar Richard
    December 26, 2012 - 10:09 pm | Permalink

    @Franklin Ryckaert:

    That’s interesting.

    I’ve never heard of that strategy before.

    (Well, maybe once or twice… but it never really registered until now.)

    I’m interested in how that strategy/idea (that you mentioned in your comment) came into existence.

    It’s as if someone realized that the current approach of demanding an end to quotas and affirmative action doesn’t appear to be working. So he (or she) paused, stepped back and asked, “What can we do now?”

    That’s such a powerful question.

    I wonder what great ideas haven’t been thought of yet, just waiting for us. Maybe some of those ideas appear relatively small or insignificant… but little things are often important and big. Like a spark.

  36. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 26, 2012 - 9:12 pm | Permalink

    @Franklin Ryckaert: Exactly. It’s a point I’ve argued for years, and one of the reasons why I still consider the vast majority of whites to be oblivios, willfully ignorant. If whites had any brains or willpower or enough concern at all to what is happening to them, (affirmative action, quotas, racial and cultural denigration,etc.etc.) they would get together and take out hundreds of lawsuits against all of the leftist organizations until the leftist damage is negated. In other words, use the lefts own weapons against them, primarily the courts.

  37. me's Gravatar me
    December 26, 2012 - 8:07 pm | Permalink

    @sanjay: “The Unz article opens the door for Asians, but not whites. Thats the key point.”
    Sanjay, actually Unz’s article’s key point is that Jews are over represented via corruption and ethinic networking – it is the NYT that reshaped the narrative.
    Unz has been at this for some time – I believe he penned an article in WJS over a decade ago making the same charge.
    “they” are not all bad, you know :)

  38. me's Gravatar me
    December 26, 2012 - 8:04 pm | Permalink

    very typical of how the jewish elite and NYT shape the narrative – they can no longer avoid the anomaly but they turn it into discrimination against asians, which 90% of readers will assume is carried out by white christians.

  39. thm's Gravatar thm
    December 26, 2012 - 7:37 pm | Permalink

    @Bobby:

    Many American Euro ethnic people are very concerned about what is happening to their country and their people but they just don’t see a way to plugin (without getting blasted with the racist, White supremacist, neo-Nazi etc label). Provide the opening and you will have many, many motivated activist people. Jewish leaders are very well aware of that, that they kind of have a tiger by the tail, and believe me, they give a lot of attention to making sure European ethnic people stay marginalized, disorganized and dispirited. Find the opening and the people will be there.

  40. Franklin Ryckaert's Gravatar Franklin Ryckaert
    December 26, 2012 - 7:10 pm | Permalink

    This whole problem of systematic dispossession of Whites can be solved by demanding consistent proportional representation in education and jobs. Jews should be counted as a separate ethnic category, which will reduce their representation to a mere 2,5% and thus end “Jewish privilege”, while Whites will get their due. Jews could only try to stop this by averting that they are not a separate ethnic group, but that could be easily refuted by their own history, behaviour, numerous ethnic organizations and above all Israel’s immigration criterium. In other words, Whites can win this battle not by trying to overthrow the system but by demanding its consistency.

  41. William's Gravatar William
    December 26, 2012 - 7:08 pm | Permalink

    I think this is a good indication of just how non-threatening The American Conservative has become. I decided to forgo renewing my subscription once it became obvious that its writers were mainly disgruntled Republicans who wished very badly to be gruntled.
    Scott McConnell, the editor, had a rather unique perspective on the recent electoin. He said that conservatives ought to reconcile themselves to multiculturalism. Why? Because a more multicultural nation was less inclined to support a neoconservative foreign policy. Isolationism uber alles!
    I have yet to revisit the website.

  42. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 26, 2012 - 6:59 pm | Permalink

    @thm: You know why whites won’t do anything about it? For the same reason that the English had the poetic joke about Hitler having only one ball. Unfortunately in the case of millions of white Americans they’re missing both. I know it’s not an answer with concrete statements backed up by all kinds of references and proof, but honestly, does anyone with eyes and ears really need the proof?

  43. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 26, 2012 - 6:43 pm | Permalink

    I see Ron Unz as the kind of intellect,(he is said to have a super high IQ), that has a touch of insanity to it, because he has written on all kinds of things that has pissed off all kinds of people. In California, he tried to get ESL, classes eliminated, which ticked off both the Mexican power groups, and/or the left.

    • Marcus's Gravatar Marcus
      December 26, 2012 - 7:51 pm | Permalink

      @Bobby:
      Jewish privilege means never having to say you’re sorry.

  44. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 26, 2012 - 6:03 pm | Permalink

    @Mary Thomas: Ditto, Mary’s observations on Latino’s here in California. BUT, fear not, those who feel left out, for it will soon be coming to your state as sure as it’s sunny in California in the summertime. Peace.

  45. Bobby's Gravatar Bobby
    December 26, 2012 - 6:00 pm | Permalink

    Mari, has again nailed it.(I’m tired of complimenting her on affirmative action, but shes’ just to correct on it all)
    ELITE WHITES, ARE THE MAIN OBSTACLE the average white population in the U.S. I’ve said this in hundreds of blogs and have no reason yet, to change my mind.

  46. thm's Gravatar thm
    December 26, 2012 - 5:50 pm | Permalink

    @ Kevin’s HuffPo link.

    After doing a little web research on Daniel Luzer, I don’t know if he is Jewish or not. However it is apparent that:
    1. He is not happy that a college is not keeping its Yiddish department.
    2. He highlighted the ADL opposition to colleges taking active economic measures against investment in Israel in response to the attacks on Gaza (ADL: it is anti-Semitic to single out Israel for its treatment of people in Gaza when there is so much other injustice in the world).
    3. He deeply supports the notion that all the Whites are historically guilty of real bad things against other ethnic groups, including by limiting Jewish admission to Ivy League schools.
    4. He promotes the idea that It is not bad that Asians are being discriminated against in college admissions to prestige schools because they are wealthy.
    5. He is absolutely totally indifferent to the marginalization of European ethnic people.
    6. He sees the increase in mass shootings as fundamentally caused by increasing economic injustice (and not the pervasive violence in video games and entertainment, the breakdown of traditional values etc) — a very Marxist view.

    If he is not, it is a distinction without a difference.

    It is so clear that there is a virtual war against people of Christian European ethnicity — your values, culture, religion, societies etc. — by a broad constellation of Jewish or Jewish controlled groups, organizations, institutions. What is mysterious to me is why this isn’t apparent to all intelligent White people and why don’t they (you) do anything about it. It seems to me that there is almost no Christian European ethnic consciousness — by far less than Black, Hispanic, Asian, Jewish or any other ethnicity you might name. If I were devoting my life to this cause, that is where i would start! And there is no greater mine of information to help in building this than Dr. MacDonalds books! When I read them, I keep finding his insights that could be used as leverage to wake people up.

    And among my first steps would be to get boots on the ground!

  47. December 26, 2012 - 5:16 pm | Permalink

    @celtthedog:
    Unz is a Jew. Sailer is a crypto-jew (currently catholic).

    The question always comes down to “Is it good for the whites?”
    The Unz article opens the door for Asians, but not whites. Thats the key point.

    Whites are like the frog in the water. They are almost cooked, unless they jump out soon.

  48. celtthedog's Gravatar celtthedog
    December 26, 2012 - 5:10 pm | Permalink

    @sanjay: I don’t disagree with either you or Professor MacDonald (thanks to both of you for kindly replying to my comment). I do remain astonished, however, that the brazen over-representation of Jews at the Ivy League has actually been acknowledged.
    But yes, you’re both correct — of and by itself it’s not enough.
    In reply to a query above, I have always understood Unz to be Jewish — I don’t have a source, unfortunately. Steve Sailer discusses him regularly and may have something.

  49. Mary Thomas's Gravatar Mary Thomas
    December 26, 2012 - 5:04 pm | Permalink

    The above comment about changing your kid’s last name is absolutely accurate. Latinos (and blacks) here in California always get a free ride, all the way through. In fact, they don’t even have to pay for college applications. They get all sorts of minority “scholarships” and aid. I don’t think white kids have access to any of that stuff. The comment that we should demand white quotas is a good one, and it should be applied in EVERY field, schools and employment, INCLUDING Wall St. and Hollywood. Let’s cut the stranglehold they have on both the media and the money supply. They’re 2 percent of the population, so that is what their numbers should be in every venue. They should not be permitted to claim to be white when it serves their purposes, and then insanely anti-white all the rest of the time.

  50. Sven's Gravatar Sven
    December 26, 2012 - 5:00 pm | Permalink

    @Kevin MacDonald 3:53 p.m.
    As he is a nobody, it’s hard to find information about him. Skimmed through his twitter page however and a high percentage of the messages he “retweet” are from people who sound or look Jewish. Usually a good sign, as you of all people would know.

  51. Marcus's Gravatar Marcus
    December 26, 2012 - 4:55 pm | Permalink

    The huffpo piece says that it’s not important who works at Goldman Sachs, only what they do there, as if the the two are totally unrelated. Typical obfuscation and sophistry.

  52. BeenThere_DoneThat's Gravatar BeenThere_DoneThat
    December 26, 2012 - 4:45 pm | Permalink

    As I had suggested elsewhere on a previous thread, if these élite universities were to exclusively admit the most talented students they could get, then who would be left to enroll in curricula preparing for degrees in, say, Journalism, Art History, Women’s Studies, International Relations, Drama, or Howl-o-Cost Studies? In my somewhat biased opinion, the seriously talented and intelligent students would shun the snobby East Coast private college scene altogether and get their degree in California.

  53. mari's Gravatar mari
    December 26, 2012 - 4:34 pm | Permalink

    I’ve never posted my solution to affirmative action discrimination on this site, but I have posted it on other White sites.

    If you have children under 13 and love them and don’t want them to end up homeless or exterminated just change their last names to an hispanic one before they start high school.

    Average White grades and SAT’s and a hispanic last name will get anyone admission and full scholarship to the ivy league. There won;t be any problem finding a job either.
    At the beginning of their junior year in college they will be getting letters from numerous employers begging them to come to work.

    The least you can do is check the black instead of the White box. Checking the White box is equivalent to signing your name Princess Tatianna Romanoff in Russia
    after the jews took over.

    Whites are marching to the abbatoir led by elite Whites. Save yourself and your family if you can. No other White will help you.

  54. mari's Gravatar mari
    December 26, 2012 - 4:25 pm | Permalink

    Holistic admissions means that the admissions board can admit anyone they want and reject every superbly qualified White.

    The usual thing is the ‘poor, poor, pitiful me” essay. Applicants are required to write an essay about their greatest struggle and how they overcame it aka mein kampf.

    So all they have to write is that they are asian and how dreadful it is. I grew up in San Marino Ca a mostly asian suburb of 10 million dollar homes. Yes, I am a member of both the Soong (bankers) and Tong (world wide construction) families. But i am a racial minority is evil racist America. The most horrible thing in my life was when an eeeviil White kid at my $7,000 per week summer camp asked me if i was Chinese or Korean. I can only recover from that horrible racist slur if I am accepted at harvard.

    One can either download these essays from the internet or pay a few hundred dollars for a custom made one.

  55. December 26, 2012 - 4:24 pm | Permalink

    @Mickey Meadows:

    these charts should be simplified to show only two bars, one for White Europeans the other for non-Whites (including jews).

  56. December 26, 2012 - 4:18 pm | Permalink

    @celtthedog:
    Unz article got the traction precisely because it fits into the minority victims evil whites narrative.

    What will happen is Jews will share a little more power with Asians, but oppression on White Europeans will actually increase.

    Jewish activists like Unz are playing a sinister role in accelerating white displacement.

    Whites are foolishly campaigning against affirmative action. What they should be fighting for is explicit White European quotas. But for that we need a strong white identity, fertility and cultural revival.

  57. fender's Gravatar fender
    December 26, 2012 - 4:10 pm | Permalink

    @ Kevin’s HuffPo link.

    “The trouble is this gross maladjustment of American wealth, not the racial or intellectual composition of the country’s richest people.”

    A perfect example of the fundamentally dishonest jewish mindset. When Whites have the wealth and power it’s because of racism and intolerance, but when jews have the wealth and power, suddenly race becomes irrelevant and we need to look into other factors. There’s no question that this guy is a member of the tribe; the surname alone is proof enough.

  58. Catiline's Gravatar Catiline
    December 26, 2012 - 4:07 pm | Permalink

    Perhaps it is time to nationalize the university system-especially the Ivies-and impose admission policies of our own. Confiscating endowments and various scholarship funds could easily fit hand in glove with nationalization.

    A possible item in a White Nationalist program of national regeneration?

  59. Mickey Meadows's Gravatar Mickey Meadows
    December 26, 2012 - 4:06 pm | Permalink

    I don’t know….but on the emotional side the revelations in the Ron Unz essay….was…..a tremendous boost to me. I literally went out jogging that night and climbed a tree in the park in the rain. They aren’t better. They aren’t in the top colleges because they are better. This is so much better to know than if they deserved it.

  60. Marcus's Gravatar Marcus
    December 26, 2012 - 3:32 pm | Permalink

    It does seem like Jews today are raising a generation of spoiled kids with all the whinyness and obnoxiousness of their forebears, but lacking the same drive to “screw the goyim,” I guess they’re used to having things handed to them now?

  61. celtthedog's Gravatar celtthedog
    December 26, 2012 - 2:28 pm | Permalink

    I’m not particularly confident about debating you, Professor MacDonald, chiefly because you’re more intelligent than me. That said, I’ll put forward the glass is half-full argument: I find it incredible that Unz’s article, which was published in a decidedly non-mainstream journal (the American Conservative is not the Atlantic or NYT Review of Books) and is by no means an easy read, has got as much traction as it has.
    And while I acknowledge that some of Unz’s key points about the grotesque level of Jewish overrepresentation in the Ivy League are being passed over, the very fact that the NY Times in general and David Brooks in particular, are having to acknowledge this overrepresentation is remarkable in itself.
    Elsewhere I predicted that Unz’s article would simply disappear into the void of a media blackout. I’m happy to have been proven wrong.

3 Trackbacks to "Ron Unz in the New York Times"

  1. on January 24, 2013 at 7:17 pm
  2. on January 24, 2013 at 1:51 pm
  3. on January 24, 2013 at 1:39 pm

Comments are closed.