Trump’s Tergiversations on Charlottesville and Their Significance

F. Roger Devlin


In the immediate aftermath of last weekend’s rioting and death in Charlottesville, VA, Pres. Donald Trump stated: “We condemn in the strongest possible terms this egregious display of hatred, bigotry and violence on many sides.”

This is about the best statement on the matter we could have hoped for from the President of the United States. In judging it, we should bear in mind his limited knowledge at that time about what had actually transpired in Charlottesville, as well as his limited knowledge of the case to be made for pro-White advocacy. The President seems to have sound instincts. He understands that as President it is his duty to condemn civil violence and lawlessness whoever commits it and however it may be motivated, and that is what he tried to do.

Predictably, a hurricane of abuse came down upon his head, perhaps best typified by John Oliver’s criticism that “it doesn’t get any easier than disavowing Nazis.” Only a Nazi, after all, could object to the removal of a statue of Robert E. Lee.

Two days later, under intense pressure, the President made a second statement which checked off all Cultural Marxism’s mandatory boxes, denouncing racism, the KKK, David Duke, Neo-Nazis, White Supremacists and people who hate cute little puppydogs. This caused consternation on our side, where some felt Trump had betrayed his supporters (see, e.g., Hunter Wallace’s remarks here). Yet it also met with little to no positive response from the anti-White establishment either: the headlines read not “Trump Denounces Racism,” but “Trump Waits Three Days to Denounce Racism.”

The President may have learned something from this experience, subsequently tweeting:

Made additional remarks on Charlottesville and realize once again that the #Fake News Media will never be satisfied…truly bad people!

The moral of the story, of course, is that it is foolish to alienate one’s friends in a futile attempt to curry favor with one’s enemies. Republicans are almost uniformly incapable of learning this simple lesson, but Trump just might do so—if he carefully bears this recent experience in mind. As I write, he is already reported to be reiterating the substance of his initial remarks at a press conference.

Listening to Trump’s second Charlottesville statement, I felt the way the average Russian must have felt listening to denunciations of “capitalism” in the Soviet Union c. 1975. It is a very specific type of oral performance peculiar to ideological regimes.

Like the Soviet Union of yore, contemporary America is in the grip of an ideology, a system of ideas not derived from any empirical study of the world around us, but which provides an account of the world, establishes an aim to be pursued and rules for pursuing it, and (most importantly) legitimates the power of some men over others. Another essential element of any ideology, as of any religion, is its demonology—an account of the enemy whom adherents must forever struggle against. Unlike personal enmities which arise through concrete social interaction, ideological enmities are established a priori by the ideology itself. In the ruling ideology of the Soviet Union, e.g., enemies included the bourgeoisie, revisionists, kulaks, and one especially nondescript class referred to simply as “enemies of the people.” In the ideology which prevails in present day America, the ideological enemies are the abstract groups denounced in Trump’s second Charlottesville remarks: racists, supremacists, haters and bigots, Nazis and the KKK. Ritual denunciation of designated enemies is an essential aspect of ideological rule, and leaders of an ideological regime cannot be considered legitimate without periodically making them. In the Soviet Union, communist politicians learned to spit out denunciations of communism’s demons in their sleep. For similar reasons, I do not share Hunter Wallace’s sense of betrayal at Trump’s second speech.

There is no objective or generally agreed-upon way of determining whether an actual person is a member of an ideologically designated category of enemies. Thus, e.g., if you had the misfortune of being designated an “enemy of the people” in the Soviet Union, you had no way to defend yourself. If you were merely accused of murder, the situation was not so desperate: everyone knows that a murderer is someone who has committed premeditated homicide, so a defense against the charge must try to demonstrate that one did not or could not have committed a particular act of homicide, or only did so without premeditation (manslaughter). But what action defines one as an “enemy of the people?”

Essentially the same situation prevails under American anti-racist ideology. There is no agreed-upon definition of racist, supremacist, bigot or Nazi. One’s membership in such supposed groups is not determined by any actions of one’s own, but arbitrarily imputed by ideological zealots, and thus no defense is possible. How could anyone prove he does not harbor “hate” in the privacy of his own mind?

Sometimes such terms apply with some clarity to a tiny core group, and ever-less-clearly to a series of concentric classes radiating outward. Thus, e.g., the most obvious candidates for being identified as “Nazis” are the LARPers of the National Socialist Movement and similar small organizations who parade about American streets with Swastika flags, etc. Even here, doubts are possible; I suspect such persons have less in common with German National Socialists of the 1930s than with Elvis impersonators and other “cosplay” fantasists (the uninitiated may cf. here). But there are not nearly enough such people to satisfy the vindictiveness of “anti-racists.”

So the next circle includes all White advocates: the sorts of people who recently tried to gather to protect the Lee statue in Charlottesville. After them come the class of Trump supporters. Then, perhaps, the class of all White people, or all Republicans, or everyone uninvolved in anti-racist activism. Adherents of anti-racist ideology compete for status by imputing Nazihood to ever-larger classes of persons. Eventually they end up accusing one another: a small and bittersweet consolation for their previous victims.

The French have a wonderful expression for this process: dérapage semantique, or “semantic skidding.” One loses control over what one’s own words refer to.

Public imputations of being an ideological enemy are a form of political combat, yet cannot be effective apart from the naïveté of the great mass of people as to what is really going on. Not being driven by ideology to stretch words to their breaking point, the man on the street is happy to join the zealots in denouncing racists, secure in the assumption that no one could ever include him in that class. But in the minds of true believers, he was devoured by that great, ever-expanding conceptual blob long ago: Ask not for whom the cry of “racism” tolls—it tolls for thee!

The victims of racism accusations usually respond with an acknowledgement that yes, of course, racism is real and must be combated; it’s just that a mistake has been made in their particular case. Does this not perhaps concede too much to our enemies? How many people have you actually encountered who strike you as being consumed with an irrational hatred people who do not look like themselves? “Racism” may be no more than a way of explaining the failure of leftists to realize their utopia of universal love.

Here again, there is a Soviet analogy. Having adopted a completely irrational form of economic production, the communist authorities encountered frequent disappointments: collapsing structures, manufactured goods unable to perform the functions for which they were intended, or failures to meet production quotas. Since the Soviet Union was presumed to possess the finest economic system in the world, such failures had to be accounted for without reference to socialism. So they were blamed on the action of “wreckers,” a class of diabolically elusive saboteurs. Countless innocent men were sent to their deaths or Siberian labor camps after being identified as “wreckers,” made into scapegoats for the failures of an unrealistic ideology.

Might there not also have been a few “real” wreckers? Perhaps: but it hardly matters. What matters is the essentially mythical nature of the concept, the need which gave rise to it, the ideological function it fulfilled—and the terrible harm and injustice which followed from it. I imagine the situation is similar with “racists.” Perhaps there really are a few people out there seething with fury at others because of “the color of their skin.” But it hardly matters. The important point is the fundamentally mythical nature of the concept, and the real injustice done to those it makes into scapegoats. White activism might even be defined as the overt public rejection of our assigned status as scapegoats for the failures of the fever-dream of “anti-racism.”

We’ll know we have won when we have a president who understands this—and is free to say so.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks

66 Comments to "Trump’s Tergiversations on Charlottesville and Their Significance"

  1. Floda's Gravatar Floda
    August 15, 2017 - 11:21 pm | Permalink

    Clearly the agenda setters in America are the same people who formed the inner sanctum of the USSR. Dr William Pierce railed against them and their ownership of the MSM and means of entertainment in Hollywood. They hate Trump because he has gone further than anyone before in de-legitimizing the ‘fake news’. The cultural war has a long way to go but at the moment I think Trump is in front.

    • Seraphim's Gravatar Seraphim
      August 18, 2017 - 5:00 am | Permalink

      All neo-cons are former Trotskysts or their descendants. ‘Antifascism’ and ‘antiStalinism’ (converted in anti-Putinism) is their default lingo. Their fury is exacerbated by the total failure of their ‘greatest realization’, the ‘glorious October Revolution’ supposed to launch the world towards the ‘golden future of Communism’ and place them once and forever on top of the world.

      • David Ashton's Gravatar David Ashton
        August 22, 2017 - 1:58 pm | Permalink

        @ Seraphim

        Leo Strauss replaced Leon Trotsky. Both writers are worth perusal, and one can perhaps thank the former for the Godwin’s Law phrase “Reduction ad Hitlerum” (but who will give credit where it’s jew?).

        The Old Jerusalem in the Middle East replaced the “New Jerusalem” in Eastern Europe after 1948, and some of the people who helped put the Soviet system up in 1917 helped to pull it down by 1991.

  2. Barkingmad's Gravatar Barkingmad
    August 15, 2017 - 11:26 pm | Permalink

    As I write, he is already reported to be reiterating the substance of his initial remarks at a press conference.

    So, here is the latest statement by Trump – as of Aug. 15th. Go to 6:20, where the good stuff starts, and watch to the end. I can’t believe my ears. He asks if “we” are going to take down statues of Washington and Jefferson, too, since they owned slaves. [Yes, I am sure they will be removed. Monticello, too.] Here and there he describes Nazis and white nationalists as the same thing.

  3. Hammerheart's Gravatar Hammerheart
    August 15, 2017 - 11:49 pm | Permalink

    Trump explicitly disavowed the White Right the next day. News media is using ‘whites’ and ‘nazi(s)’ and ‘white supremacist’ interchangeably. There is no real cause for celebration.

    • Barkingmad's Gravatar Barkingmad
      August 16, 2017 - 2:43 pm | Permalink

      Doesn’t matter if the news media use those 3 terms interchangeably. Every one of us could be pure as the driven snow with not so much as a parking ticket to our name; helping out Mother Teresa in India; feeding blacks, doing relief work in dark parts of the world at our own expense, and so on. Makes no difference to them.

      • David Ashton's Gravatar David Ashton
        August 17, 2017 - 10:00 am | Permalink

        @ Barkingmad

        True enough, but one must avoid giving those who control the narrative gratuitous factual ammunition which can deflect potential support away from patriots.

        They WANT martyrs – from MLK to Little Trayvon. Down comes General Lee, one of the finest Americans who ever lived, and up goes a monument to poor Heather Heyer.

  4. August 16, 2017 - 12:36 am | Permalink

    You are brilliant, plain and simple.

  5. JimB's Gravatar JimB
    August 16, 2017 - 12:43 am | Permalink

    What really gets me in any of these interviews and discourses is the assumption that if you really ARE a neo-Nazi or member of an explicitly pro-White group, a self-identified White Nationalist, say, the assumption is that you, as a neo-Nazi or White Nationalist, shouldn’t be allowed to assemble or exorcise your freedom of speech. Just listen to some of the Alt-Lite “patriot” types, saying things like “…well, not all of us at the Unite The Right rally were neo-Nazis…”, implicitly agreeing that actual “racists” DON’T deserve to assemble and have their voices heard! But, on the other hand, no one raises the same objections when The New Black Panthers come together publicly and/or show up at the voting booths WITH GUNS shouting “We need to start killing White babies!” Members of the group don’t meet ANY hostility from the majority of normal people, they aren’t stigmatized by the media as “black supremacists” or “racists”, no one throws bottles and swings sticks at their heads, etc. And NO ONE, politician or regular Joe Public, even suggests that they be shut-down and not allowed to speak!!! The hypocrisy is so over-the-top, it’s maddening.
    EVERYONE has the right to free speech. EVERYONE has the right to assemble as a political group. YES, EVEN NEO-NAZIS, THE KKK, AND ANY OTHER “WHITE SUPREMACIST” GROUP!!!!! If black-supremacists can assemble, shouting “we need to kill White babies!”, toting fucking GUNS even, showing up at voting booths to intimidate people(!), if Latino/Mestizo supremacists can assemble, shouting “Fuck America! Make America Mexico Again!”, if Antifa can assemble, waving COMMUNIST flags (the communists have been responsible for HUNDREDS OF MILLIONS of deaths), if BlackLivesMatter can assemble, calling for the deaths of our policemen, etc., etc., etc., then goddammit neo-Nazis and White Nationalist in general ALSO get to assemble!!!
    Communist fuckers, black and other non-white racist haters, understand these words: THOSE WHO MAKE PEACEFUL REVOLUTION IMPOSSIBLE WILL MAKE VIOLENT REVOLUTION INEVITABLE. JFK said that. Let it sink in!!!

    • Michael Adkins's Gravatar Michael Adkins
      August 16, 2017 - 7:37 am | Permalink

      JimB,

      In my opinion, ABC, CBS and NBC are beginning to over play their hand. Most people in this country can see through them.

      • pterodactyl's Gravatar pterodactyl
        August 17, 2017 - 3:23 am | Permalink

        Michael Adkins – correct, people see through them, and the only reason they say nothing is that they can see who has the upper hand – for now. But when the wind starts to change these people will quickly and readily change allegiance, as their natural nature is self-preservation, not the current self-hate that they are going along with for now.

    • Leon Haller's Gravatar Leon Haller
      August 17, 2017 - 4:16 pm | Permalink

      Not really. There is no right to free speech, nor should there be. Political speech should be confined within certain parameters, those having to do with ultimate national security and preservation. Do communists have a right to disseminate their lies and evil desires freely? Do black supremacists wishing to enslave and exterminate Whites have a right to speak freely?

      The FOUNDATIONAL problem with America is that we did not define our nation racially from the Constitutional beginning. We should have had it in the Constitution that the US is a White nation; that ONLY Whites can be either residents or citizens of the USA; and that this status can never be amended. In such a case, it would have taken a true Bolshevik revolution to have changed America, and that never would have happened.

      Free speech was meant to allow for the free flow of ideas within a common, genetically linked national “family”, so that ideas could be considered dispassionately without fear of future retribution. It was never intended to protect those who were advocating the nation’s destruction.

      The larger point is that speech must take place within certain System- conserving boundaries. This position embodies true, classical conservatism. Free speech was always a liberal innovation based on liberal (and distinctly anti-clerical) premises. The problem today is simply that our race has become utterly ideologically corrupted, so much so that we actually work to exterminate ourselves (talk about evolutionary losers!). In this dire situation, of course we powerless White Preservationists must work within a hostile system, and therefore defend the sacrality of free expression.

  6. Trenchant's Gravatar Trenchant
    August 16, 2017 - 1:24 am | Permalink

    Interesting that the WN-terrorism meme was immediately floated by former State Department psy-ops player, Brennan Gilmore. Right spot, right time, as serendipity would have it. http://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2017/08/random-man-protests-interviewed-msnbc-ny-times-deep-state-shill-linked-george-soros/

  7. Ger Tzedek's Gravatar Ger Tzedek
    August 16, 2017 - 2:00 am | Permalink

    I have the impression that Trump only wants to bring the problem to the forefront, nothing else.

  8. John C.'s Gravatar John C.
    August 16, 2017 - 4:12 am | Permalink

    Unless you believe White people are “evil” you are evil. That is the mantra being forced by the Left and Black racists. White people are waking up to the anti-White hatred because it is so extreme. That may be a good thing.

    • pterodactyl's Gravatar pterodactyl
      August 17, 2017 - 3:33 am | Permalink

      John C’s comment is relevant to: “How many people have you actually encountered who strike you as being consumed with an irrational hatred of people who do not look like themselves? ”
      – the answer is, plenty of people in the third world who are genetically tribal in nature. These are racist people from the third world who hate us, who the Left wish to invite over to the West. Their countries of origin are poor because they are so tribal. The best person is never given the job. The only race that is not racist is the white race. That is why it is easy for the left to persuade them to have no loyalty to their own race – to hate it even. The left could NEVER persuade the people of some African country to hate their own (assuming they would want to). They could never persuade Pakistanis to hate their own. Only whites can be persuaded to hate their own (for now) as only white are sufficiently individualistic in their genes for this to work. But although it works for now, whites have another characteristic – they readily absorb and follow the message of the culture, and as soon as this message of the culture shifts from self-hate to self-preservation they will quickly change their views. It is quite a feat for the left to keep the people in their current state of self-hate, but it will not be so easy for the left to sustain this state of self-harm when the people are no longer safe and wealthy.

  9. RoyAlbrecht's Gravatar RoyAlbrecht
    August 16, 2017 - 6:20 am | Permalink

    From among the exponentially swelling ranks of the White Advocacy cohort, one “…cannot infrequently…” hear denunciations of Trump’s failures or his cow towing to “…the Jews..” etc… and,
    anyone who cuts him a bit of slack is ipso facto a fool because Trump is really a tool of the Jew World Order.

    These hard liners who denounce Trump may well prove to be right in the end and,
    since I pride myself on being able to see what is coming down the pipes long before it has materialized,
    my reputation as a credible prognosticator means a lot to me.

    However, I just cannot write Trump off just yet.

    Trump comes from a merchant-working class background/genealogy..,
    even though his personal story has been more of a “…bean counting, construction project managerial, real estate speculative and most recently billionaire entertainment…” one.

    I do not consider Trump to be a natural genius like say for example Thomas Edison, Alexander Graham Bell or Max Planck. Trump is more of a “…ground and pound, Brock Lessner…” type as opposed to a “…gifted artist, Rudolph Nureyev…” type.

    Moreover, having made the judgment to muscle his way into New York in pursuit of his money accumulating objectives, a by product of this move has been the “…loss…” of Trump’s children to the All Consumptive Beast of International Jewry.

    Moreover, Trump has had to adopt the Schizophrenic Nature of World Jewry at a relatively young age…,
    if only to survive in the business environment he chose to commit himself to.

    All the above aside, I get the feeling that Trump knows that Jews are largely a Filthy, Cunning, Condescending, Duplicitous Lot, but at this stage of the game,
    for reasons of habituation, implicit Social Construct Adaptation, his children, his accumulated state of denial and Jew-induced Mass Stockholm Syndrome of the people who elected him…, I reckon it will take a few more years of Jews “…pushing Trumps ‘..White Buttons..’ ” before he actually blows his top and really says.., “..Enough is Enough !!..”.

    In the mean time, White Advocates are going to have to “…suck it up…” and continue to digest and reorder the ridiculous and largely undefinable abuse by Jews that has been alluded to in the above essay.

    After all, considering the past 100 odd years of down right danger that White Advocates have had to deal with
    (i.e. State Sanctioned Murders, False Imprisonment,
    Jew owned Mass Media and NGO libel, defamation and slander,
    rigged courts, Jew Proxy Controlled Law Enforcement Criminals, etc…)
    White Advocates’ prospects have taken a marked improvement in circumstances under the Trump Administration.

    Mind you, the improvement was due to come sooner or later anyhow…, because,
    as the author above has alluded to,
    the premise upon which the Jewish Paradigm is based is largely absurdly abstract and due to collapse with or without Trump’s help.

    As I see it, “Our” job is to continue to reach out to the “Aspiring Everyman Aryans,
    no matter what Racial admixtures they have been bequeathed with,
    until such time that Trump has an absolute and unequivocal majority that “…Gets the JQ…”,
    so that he himself can finally and explicitly be the White Man/Aryan that I believe he is in his heart of Hearts.

    • RoyAlbrecht's Gravatar RoyAlbrecht
      August 16, 2017 - 10:34 am | Permalink

      Just now I am listening to a press conference that Trump gave regarding Charlottesville.
      To me, on balance, it was more “…pro Alt-Right…” than his previous press conferences.
      Further, he correctly Identified the Left for the crimes they committed…,
      including the armed violence,
      the unpermitted (Read: illegal) nature of (((their))) counter demonstration,
      and the fake news coverage of what actually took place
      (i.e. R.E. Lee statue dispute and where to draw the line regarding taking down of historical monuments, who was the actual perpetrator of most of the violence, etc…).

      Given the (((psychologically captive audience))) he is addressing, namely the American public…, he is doing his best.

      What is even more positive for us is the fact that Trump actually mentions the name of David Duke in the press conference.
      This event is most certainly being covered by EVERY NEWS NETWORK IN THE NATION AND PROBABLY QUITE A FEW OUTSIDE THE NATION AS WELL.

      Trump has given us a major break.

      As a result of his merely mentioning Dr. D. Duke,
      search engine searches will no doubt take a spike in our direction,
      so he has…,
      and I believe he has done this quite knowingly…,
      given us the opportunity to logically explain what is going on regarding the JQ.

      Just like I said above, Trump wants us to do the heavy lifting for him so he can pick up Our ball and eventually set things right.

      • David Ashton's Gravatar David Ashton
        August 20, 2017 - 12:35 pm | Permalink

        The question is: can/does Trump do “subtle”?

        The rise of the KKK – the Kosher Kushner Kabinet?

        • RoyAlbrecht's Gravatar RoyAlbrecht
          August 21, 2017 - 11:32 am | Permalink

          “…subtle…” is Trump’s middle name:

          > Mentioning Dr. D. Duke at the Charlottesville press conference,

          > The 6 pointed star “…affair…” during campaign and his “…loopy eared…” defense against the Anti-Semite charges was his “…Sherriff’s Star…” claim,

          > Filling his cabinet…, “…wall to wall…” I might add…, with Zionist Jews is basically sending out an invitation for us to attack him on this point!…, although Trump dare not say so publically…

          > Listen to his Republican Jewish Coalition speech before getting elected…
          It is replete with subtle insinuations that require an implicit understanding of Jewish Behavioral Psychology more typical of people with IQs that are 20 to 30 points above the people whom he is speaking to at a “…normal mainstream gathering…”,

          > Hiring and then firing Steve Bannon…, even though Bannon is a Cucked-up retard…, again…, it moves the topic of the JQ in Our direction,

          > Hesitancy to “…disavow Duke immediately…” back when he was still a candidate,

          Are the number of times Trump has “…subtly…” gotten the Jews themselves to initiate the usual Pavlovian Anti-Semite or Hitler accusations only to have an “innocent” excuse at the tip of his tongue just “…coincidence…” ?

          Remember…, Trump basically grew up in NY surrounded by “…Jewish Snakes…”. I’ll bet he knows the Jews better than they know themselves.

          • David Ashton's Gravatar David Ashton
            August 21, 2017 - 2:47 pm | Permalink

            @ RoyAlbrecht

            Well, analyze e.g. his AIPAC address. Maybe there is more to him than the vulgar twittering egomaniac he appears to observers on all sides of politics. One hopes so.

            He certainly knew e.g. Roy Cohn, and relies on Stephen Miller.

            You must have read all the recent stuff from the Chabad-Kushners and Marc Schulman’s Newsweek “Tel Aviv Diary” on the Donald-Bibi partnership.

            British leftist Ian Birrell comments sarcastically in “The Independent”, August 21, that “people can draw comfort from chaos and incompetence that would usually be cause for concern…core pledges have fallen from view…. Trump’s contempt for voters was exposed in the leaked transcript of a phone call to Mexican President” in which he said the border wall was “the least important thing we are talking about, but politically it might be the most important”.
            You could be right, or wrong. The proof of the kugel will be in the eating at the next Presidential election.

    • Tony Clifton's Gravatar Tony Clifton
      August 16, 2017 - 7:43 pm | Permalink

      Shortly after Hurricane Katrina destroyed much of the Mississippi Gulf Coast in 2005, a member of the Sons of Confederate Veterans told me that Donald Trump had donated $25,000 for the restoration of badly damaged Beauvoir — President Jefferson Davis’ beachfront home at the time of his death. I always cut him slack for his “original instincts.” Or it could have been an act of penance for that statue of the war criminal General Tecumseh Sherman in NYC’s Central Park. God forbid his opposition hears about this.

  10. RHW's Gravatar RHW
    August 16, 2017 - 6:24 am | Permalink

    “Two days later, under intense pressure, the President made a second statement which checked off all Cultural Marxism’s mandatory boxes”

    It follows a pattern of Trump going back on his original instincts. The Jew-ridden deep state is responsible for all the U-turning he’s doing and frankly Trump doesn’t know the pressures he’s surrounded by, most of which will be masquerading as “help”, unanimity of expert opinion on something, moralized urgencies etc.

    He’s a great campaigner and generator of “energy”, but he isn’t cut out for the cant and mendacity pervading government. And when there’s enough cumulative soft pressures applied under the table, behind your back etc. it becomes hard pressure. I guarantee they’ve been playing a long game of either impeaching or easing Trump out, and the recent events in charlottesville have given them the shits.

  11. RoyAlbrecht's Gravatar RoyAlbrecht
    August 16, 2017 - 7:21 am | Permalink

    From the Occidental Dissent Article referred to in the above essay:

    http://www.occidentaldissent.com/2017/08/14/donald-trumps-horrifying-charlottesville-statement/

    “…The Alt-Right will stand with White Americans who are under siege in Trump’s America who have been deserted by their president.”

    The site above is not my cup of tea. They are milk toast on the Jewish Question and as such routinely avoid the 800 tonne gorilla in the room…
    At times I have found their publications so infantile as to be down right laughable.

    Nevertheless, Trump’s lack of explicit and unbiased support of the Alt-Right,
    not to mention the many White victims that were merely exercising their 1st Amendment rights,
    is giving the “…Alt-right…” exactly the toe hold it needs to co-opt the entire White Base.

    Remember, every time Trump denies the righteously deserved support to his White Base, and the Alt-right does what White Nationalists et al have been doing for the last 100 years and gives these disenfranchised “…Aryans…” the support they rightfully deserve, We score another point and our ranks will continue to grow.

    This sort of continued denial by Trump and WN/S/A’s stepping in to support these abused masses, simply continue to cause Our ranks to swell until we will have co-opted the leadership of the Main Steam American Aryan Masses.

    If Trump, or whoever follows in his foot steps, does not address the injustices Trump’s present failings are fueling, David Duke will one day find himself sitting in the office of the POTUS.

    Moreover, during the election I distinctly remember Trump telling his supporters that they should fight back against the [Jew Funded] Anti-fa because police just do not have the resources to combat the enormity that composed these Leftist Mobs.
    So it is not entirely true that Trump has “…deserted…” his supporters.
    Trump is a savvy business man and knows when to go “…all in…” and now is not the time for him to do so.
    The Alt Right must continue to take the heat for a little while longer until the tipping point is reached and Trump has the confidence that he can indeed “.go all in..” and join the Aryan Cause against the Jew World Order.

    • Realist's Gravatar Realist
      August 17, 2017 - 12:53 am | Permalink

      For us White Nationalists, we better understand that we have no friends outside the movement.
      Trump is not our friend, and for those that thought Steve Bannon was a friend here is his latest comment.
      Bannon dismissed the far-right as irrelevant:

      “Ethno-nationalism—it’s losers. It’s a fringe element. I think the media plays it up too much, and we gotta help crush it, you know, uh, help crush it more.”

      “These guys are a collection of clowns,” he added.

      • Barkingmad's Gravatar Barkingmad
        August 17, 2017 - 7:49 am | Permalink

        Indulge me here for a bit, friends.

        “I have a dream!”, too. It’s that the system has broken down: no food in the supermarkets or anywhere, little reliable electricity or water delivery, roaming gangs, houses’ windows boarded up for protection, infrastructure busted up, etc. Army seizing our food. And then Bannon and his ilk stumble upon my little redoubt in the hills, begging for succor. And then I deal with the situation but not how they want.

        Why these over-the-top, childish desires? Watching the news “reporting” and commentary on Charlottesville in the mainstream media is what done it for me. Then seeing Spencer and the others either being (apparently) genuinely shocked that things occurred the way they did. I imagine most of you could see it coming a mile away.

        • RoyAlbrecht's Gravatar RoyAlbrecht
          August 17, 2017 - 12:24 pm | Permalink

          Images of Schadenfreude dance in my head…, believe me…, I know the feeling.

          Was Bannon not the Shabbat Goy FOUNDER of Breitbart, only to be FORCED OUT by the very Jews that he hired?…, and then later FORCED OUT of the Trump administration probably due to pressure applied to Trump by the Jews surrounding Trump?

          Sounds to like the guy is a CLASS “A” idiot to me.

          If that is true.., then I wouldn’t give him a second thought.

          He comes across as largely irrelevant and to make matters worse, that retarded idiot is still socking Jewish cuck and slamming Us Whites !!

          With all due respect…, and it took me a while for this lesson to sink in as well…, giving a guy like that the intellectual time of day makes you/me/anyone, my friend, look like an even greater idiot! LOL

          If some White guy is a Jew-induced retard, you do not need to overly concern yourself with him…,
          for one day his anger will reach the boiling point and that will be the day that the “…Blue Pill…” will take effect.
          It will also be the day that we will have another Mighty Whitey battling in Our ranks against the Slithering Jew Incarnate.

          • Livonia's Gravatar Livonia
            August 19, 2017 - 2:31 pm | Permalink

            Bannon was not a founder of Breitbart. The founder clearly was Andrew Breitbart, himself a Jew. The Breitbart site idea was conceived in Israel, and implemented in USA. After Breitbart dead, Bannon took over,

  12. Forever guilty's Gravatar Forever guilty
    August 16, 2017 - 7:46 am | Permalink

    “Having adopted a completely irrational form of economic production”

    USSR was one of 2 superpowers, when it had central planing system with reasonably good level of living , powerful economics and enormous military force , today with “market economy” its 3rd world economic cesspool behind Brazil, and South Korea.

    Its impossible to have modern economy without some long term planing and resource allocation. Modern countries like China, South Korea, Germany, Japan, understand that very well.

    “So they were blamed on the action of “wreckers,” a class of diabolically elusive saboteurs”

    I’m not historian. But I think “saboteurs “ and “spies”, that from Stalin epoch. Soviets in 1970th had it very good economically.

    Actually there is a lot reasons for socialist like economical system (especially in mono ethnic society ). Unfortunately today’s “lefts” are completely about anti-White racism, not economics. They do not care about (((financial parasites))) and pitchforks , they care about “White privilege” , “White supremacists” , “White Nazis” “White exploitation” etc. Actually, how (((Soros))), who is billionaire could be described as “left” is beyond my comprehension.

    • Sam Dewn's Gravatar Sam Dewn
      August 16, 2017 - 9:13 am | Permalink

      “USSR was one of 2 superpowers, when it had central planing system with reasonably good level of living , powerful economics and enormous military force…”

      You are confusing this site with a standup comedy club. “reasonably good level of living”, really? Have you lived through, as you call it, “good times in the USSR”? because I have and it was anything but. You better reread articles on this site pointing out who the bolsheviks really were and how they came to power. Because, what has happening to Western White Civilization is a repeat of the European, in particular German and Russian, history before and during the WW1. And we all know where it led to. None of it is about economy any more. It is about one thing and one thing only, RACE. It is about the our children and their children.

    • August 17, 2017 - 1:01 pm | Permalink

      “Soviets in 1970[s] had it very good economically.”
      You don’t know what you’re talking about. The above contradicts every first hand account I have ever read or heard.

      • Forever guilty's Gravatar Forever guilty
        August 17, 2017 - 7:13 pm | Permalink

        “You don’t know what you’re talking about.”

        I wandering about «fist hand account» of yours. Actually I heard, read more positive “fist hand” accounts”.

        Like people starting getting their fist free individual apartments in 1960.. 70.. . Well it wasn’t really free of course. Society has to pay in the end.

        Free medical care , actually as I understand medicine in USSR was more based on preventive care. there were a lot of local clinics and people were getting frequent check-ups which helped discover health problems earlier. Also doctors house calls were standard. If somebody got seek , he called his local clinic at morning and was visited by doctor some time later in that day. And medications cost 20 – 30 kopeeks. ( High end “elite” medicine was probably better in the West )

        Symbolic utility bills like 20 rubles for 3 months gas , water and electricity. Symbolic public transport fees 3-5 kopeek a trip ( 1 kopeek its like 1 cent ) 30 rubles 2000 km long air-plane ticket.

        Oh and free education of course. Students in University were actually paid small stipend by state and provided free( admittedly low quality ) accommodation for students who needed it.

        Could you claim that all of above is a lie?.

        • T. J.'s Gravatar T. J.
          August 18, 2017 - 12:35 pm | Permalink

          Everything the Soviets had was given up by, or stolen from, the West. Tech, factories, and son. Ford built a truck plant in 1972 [Kama River]. One example of hundreds.

          Antony Sutton – Western Technology & Soviet Economic Development (1987)

          • David Ashton's Gravatar David Ashton
            August 20, 2017 - 12:31 pm | Permalink

            Anthony Sutton “minimized” the “Jewish” role in the October Revolution.

  13. Sam Dewn's Gravatar Sam Dewn
    August 16, 2017 - 9:42 am | Permalink

    People, what difference does it make what he said or didn’t say, what any of them did or didn’t do or said or didn’t say. None, none what so ever. All we do is spinning the wheels when reacting to the pseudo-events projected upon us by the (((tribe))). Our race is being exterminated, not displaced. Yes, we are being exterminated. And unless you want to see your children’s throats cut, your girls raped and their bodies mutilated and your boys tortured and murdered you better understand that it is a war for survival. Next time you see a White child you better ask yourself, “Do I want this child to be save and have children of its own”?

    • Nick Dean's Gravatar Nick Dean
      August 18, 2017 - 2:18 pm | Permalink

      99% right. You lose 1% for employing the pseudo-activist parentheses given you by a _ike.

      Alt-wrong; White correct.

  14. Amalek's Gravatar Amalek
    August 16, 2017 - 10:31 am | Permalink

    The Jews looted the Soviet and moved to America. Now they are looting America with plans to move to Greater Israel. The “wreckers” are the scapegoats the Jews projected their parasitic nation wrecking upon.

  15. Curmudgeon's Gravatar Curmudgeon
    August 16, 2017 - 11:39 am | Permalink

    There are a number of things missed by the author. The fact that Trump had the audacity to include the Antifa crowd in his first statement, was the real reason for the outrage. In the video posted by Barkingmad, Trump, on several occasions, refers to his statements, unlike the fake news, being based on accurate information and that all of the facts are still not known. He also made the point that the protesters surrounding the Lee statue had a permit, while the counter-protesters did not.
    What does Trump have up his sleeve? There were reports that Craigslist, in the C’ville area had ads for protesters at a demonstration for $25/hr. If true, does this give the DOJ an opening to investigate? Who knows? Maybe Trump has hired them to discredit the Antifa gang. Like so many other fake news narratives, I sense the majority of people will see this one as another nail in the fake news coffin.
    As for Mr. Devlin’s references to the USSR, I can only be amused. Having real Soviets, an East German and Czechoslovakians in my university class in the early 70s made me realize that there was really little difference between the mindset of Soviet and US politicians. Sure the Soviet politicians had memorized excuses for the shortcomings of the system, but how is that any different than the US politicians of the day having worn out excuses the shortcomings of the US system? “Efficient” US manufacturing spawned the Pinto and Vega as a response to the ’72 oil shortage. The “wreckers”, in my opinion, were real, the (((usual suspects))) and in both camps. There was a reason for the sudden desire for aliyah among Soviet Jews in the late 60s and 70s, and it wasn’t Khruschchev.

  16. Martin's Gravatar Martin
    August 16, 2017 - 1:04 pm | Permalink

    Trump isn’t the full package by any means. But full credit to him for continuing the fist fight with the MSM opinion formers.

  17. T. J.'s Gravatar T. J.
    August 16, 2017 - 1:21 pm | Permalink

    AMERICA WAS FOUNDED ON THE BASIS OF WHITE NATIONALISM

    See the Naturalization Act of 1790

    SUMMARY

    This article of legislation allowed an individual to apply for citizenship if they were a free white person, being of good character, and living in the United States for two years. Upon receiving the courts approval they took an oath of allegiance which was recorded. The individual’s citizenship was also extended to any children under the age of 21, regardless of their birthplace. If the applicant had never been a U.S. resident the application was disregarded.

    President Trump, in comdemning White Nationalism, was comdemning the Founding Fathers!

    • RoyAlbrecht's Gravatar RoyAlbrecht
      August 17, 2017 - 7:58 am | Permalink

      This is an excellent point !!! Kudos to you for reviving it.

      The problem with the hard and, to me, quite normal truth that you reiterate is that there are a lot of people who support what WN/S/As stand for but are NOT FULLY White !!

      Now, I am not much for minding the sensibilities of non-Whites…, or anyone for that matter.

      Living in Iceland largely affords one the luxury of being Brutally Frank about EVERY topic under the sun…,
      including LBTGQ & other forms of both mental and physical retardation, Jews (redundant…, I know…), Racial cranial anthropometric realities vs. IQ, and just about anything you can think of including harshly criticizing Iceland or Icelanders,
      but America is NOT composed of Icelanders YET America,
      under the thumb of the International Jews,
      presently sets the agenda.., either by hook or by crook.., that the rest of the world MUST follow.

      As such, some Americans DO get offended and WILL become violent if their inner sanctimonious paradigm is disrupted… And since the Global,
      especially the world-wide White and in particular the American National,
      population is on the cusp of openly debating the JQ,
      the International Jew is insanely driven to causing wide spread civil war in America…,
      if only to keep the average American from openly debating the JQ.

      As Aryans and White Advocates…, we must act in a way that nullifies the Jewish attempt to spark mass violence otherwise things will get a lot worse before they get better…

      Do we really want to go through hell to get to peace when we can just clean up the Jews and get back to business as usual?

  18. Zaida's Gravatar Zaida
    August 16, 2017 - 2:06 pm | Permalink

    Interestingly it wasn’t the antifa mental defectives the most numerous group protesting the patriots, but the Christian mental defectives. ” Workers of the world unite” is merely a variation of “In Christ we’re one”. Never heard of one single Christian church supporting Europeans, White people, though they all support immigrants, refugees, even Muslims.

    • David Ashton's Gravatar David Ashton
      August 20, 2017 - 12:27 pm | Permalink

      “Love thy enemies” + self-abnegating guilt = the elements of Christianity which have outlasted the particular religious belief (which alone conceivably justified them) and survived in the secular mutation of “left-liberalism”. A recipe for collective suicide?

      • HK Wills's Gravatar HK Wills
        August 20, 2017 - 5:56 pm | Permalink

        They misapply intra-tribal ethics to the inter-tribal level: maladaptive to say the least.

  19. AD's Gravatar AD
    August 16, 2017 - 3:02 pm | Permalink

    Another tour de force. Dr. Devlin, you are my favorite thinker on the right other than the incomparable KMac.

    • Luke's Gravatar Luke
      August 17, 2017 - 6:43 am | Permalink

      I also like most of Devlin’s material. Ed Connelly is a guy that I would place on a even ranked position alongside Kmac.

      I always look forward to Ed Connelly’s insight and analysis.

  20. quackademic's Gravatar quackademic
    August 16, 2017 - 3:08 pm | Permalink

    Any pro-White preservationists who are condemned as “haters” by fellow Whites should retort “It’s Better To Be A Hater Than A Traitor!”.

  21. Tom's Gravatar Tom
    August 16, 2017 - 3:16 pm | Permalink

    It appears that European-derived peoples are willingly being co-opted by those of other phenotypes. The co-option is primarily intellectual, emotional, and attitudinal at present. In the future, it’ll probably also be genetic. Maybe that’s how the Neanderthals became incorporated into the Cro-Magnon. The former were just so damned “nice”, “inclusive”, “welcoming”, and “judgment-free” that they lapsed into extinction.

  22. MGD's Gravatar MGD
    August 16, 2017 - 5:53 pm | Permalink

    “I suspect such persons have less in common with German National Socialists of the 1930s than with Elvis impersonators and other “cosplay” fantasists”

    BEWARE THE FURRED REICH!!!!!
    http://www.newstatesman.com/science-tech/social-media/2017/02/furred-reich-truth-about-nazi-furries-and-alt-right

  23. MGD's Gravatar MGD
    August 16, 2017 - 6:00 pm | Permalink

    “Eventually they end up accusing one another: a small and bittersweet consolation for their previous victims”

    It’s funny you should mention that……..

    http://www.occidentaldissent.com/2017/08/16/goldman-sachs-discriminating-against-black-jewish-bankers/

    The best part?

    “Allen says her supervisor met with Minnis about the decision and said she made racist and anti-Semitic comments about Allen, who is also Jewish.”

    lolololol!!!

  24. ilena's Gravatar ilena
    August 17, 2017 - 12:27 am | Permalink

    I agreed with Trump’s first comment he made about the situation. And I don’t think he should have tried to appease the Leftists. It only made it worse for him.
    I’m reading ‘The Gulag Archipelago’ right now, as well as Kevin Macdonald’s “Culture of Critique”. That ANTIFA is an example of a product of both the cultures in both books; from the Bolshevik’s totalitarianism to the Jewish Intellectuals who have been influencing and guiding the West straight to the “gulag”, it’s literally terrifying to watch this ANTIFA, some carrying Soviet flags….
    It’s going to take me awhile to read both books, because I have to pause to absorb and think about them. But I wish more people would read this stuff. It’s powerful.
    We never learned about what was going on in the USSR when I was in school. It was always a huge mystery. I remember learning about the Nazis and all the lampshades made from Jewish skin. I remember all the dead bodies stacked up. Of course, it came out later there was no truth to the lampshades and soap, and many other things. But all the truth about the Bolsheviks and Marxism seems to have been purposely concealed….or maybe the information just didn’t make it to my neighborhood.

    • David Ashton's Gravatar David Ashton
      August 17, 2017 - 10:05 am | Permalink

      I would recommend also Eugene Methvin’s “The Riot Makers: The Technology of Social Demolition” (1970!!) which filled in the “how” details of Spengler’s warning that “race and class war would one day combine to finish off the white world”.

  25. Mr Curious's Gravatar Mr Curious
    August 17, 2017 - 4:28 am | Permalink

    New Rules for MScuM

    1) When you refer to AltRight rallies as “far right / white supremacist yadda yadda”, you also refer to BLM poztard rallies as “far left, marxist, black supremacist, black nationalist” .

    2) no glorifying useful idiot snow bunny sluts whose unwashed coalition of the fringes uses Soros’s $g gazillion to violently assailt based legal Core Americans like Mr Kessler.

    3) No glorifying imbecile diversotard quota hires whi have an 80IQ & throw a tantrum when CEO despite knowing less science than your tupical Wjite 12yo boy.

    2) when you ask Trump on cobnections to KKK etc, you also ask The Witch aboit her support for much more egregious terrorisy organisations like Isis, blm, ((($plc))), uou biased jounosluts.

  26. August 17, 2017 - 7:44 am | Permalink

    “Tergiversations”? Someone’s been reading Simon Sheppard! haha.

    Fact of the matter is, you in the USA are heading for a European-style crackdown on anything white and racial.

    Here in GB, post-Charlottesville, we’ve had ‘politicians’ boldly state that ANYTHING that is ‘anti-Nazi’ [sic!] is good – including militant Bolshevism/Anarchism!. In other words, anything that runs counter to the welfare and continued advancement of the Jewish race A) must be destroyed at all costs, and B) in doing so, ANY ideological opponent of Aryan interests will be commissioned as an actual ally so long as it is vehemently ‘anti-Nazi’, and therefore such allies will have their own historical crimes conveniently swept under the rug and will be given the power to act, by the powers that be (fundamentally, the oberjuden or their non-Jew proxies).

    However, yet again, the unthinking vermin of the ‘Antifa’ cannot see that they are merely the hired bootboys of the oberjuden and the parasitic capitalist class. Some things never change!

  27. Paul's Gravatar Paul
    August 17, 2017 - 9:25 am | Permalink

    I said it last year. I never bought into this Trump messiah con.

    He is just playing a sly game to con simpletons especially in the South. He has already changed his position. Forget CNN etc. Pressure will keep piling especially since we have a Jewish family in the White House plus his administration is full of them.

  28. Doug M's Gravatar Doug M
    August 17, 2017 - 9:59 am | Permalink

    Once more, we are allowing the “enemy” to define us. We are not “White Supremicists,” we are DEFENDERSS of White people who are under constant attack by, of all people, self-destructive whites, i.e., the white bien pensant.
    Nothing happens when a figure like Oprah Winfrey says the solution to the racial problem is the death of “old White men”.
    So far as I can tell , that statement went uncontested by any public opposition.
    WE need to accurately define ourselves as “defenders” of White people, not White supremicists.

    • Charles Frey's Gravatar Charles Frey
      August 17, 2017 - 9:42 pm | Permalink

      Doug, of all the comments on this site, for some time, yours is the most valuable and correct; and of greater relevance than some ancient Greek’s bath-room habits.

      Supremacist, of any variety evokes unpleasant images and connotations: let’s cede that term to the self-acclaimed Jewish goals of their God-sponsored Supremacy and call ourselves Defenders: a functionally far more accurate term.

      I bring the motion, that we adopt this term on this site and make our best efforts to have it travel to other sites as well.

    • Walteress's Gravatar Walteress
      August 18, 2017 - 7:46 pm | Permalink

      ‘We’ don’t call ourselves supremicists. Fake news calls us such. If they can twist the potus words, they can twist our collective name. Perhaps it’s time to start calling the spades, Spades. Also known as jews. If not now, then very, very soon.

  29. Josef Fenrin's Gravatar Josef Fenrin
    August 17, 2017 - 11:41 am | Permalink

    The (((fake news people))).

    • Josef Fenrin's Gravatar Josef Fenrin
      August 17, 2017 - 11:56 am | Permalink

      The hypocrisy of the (((MSM))) is truly astounding. Endless fake reporting on the alleged violent behaviour of white advocates.

      I didn’t here a single report in the news of how Baked Alaska had acid thrown in his face and was blinded by Antifa while the death of SJW Heather Heyer is front page news across the globe.

  30. August 17, 2017 - 3:23 pm | Permalink

    Here is a fascinatingbook about how word based organizations control human populations.

    Word Controlled Humans is well worth the read as it contains a most interesting description about the development of Jews and their religion through the use of words. What is most interesting and enlightening is the author’s views on German culture during Roman times. His description serves to explain why Jews are antithetical to Germans and why they harbor such vehement hatred for these people.

    Essentially Mr. Harland says that “monster” group organizations are fomented and controlled by words. Such groups were known in ancient times as “Serpents” or “Dragons”.

    Group sovereignty, forced on individuals by a word manipulated group, is the way of the serpent. The advocates of such a direction have always claimed that anyone who advocated individual sovereignty was immoral. The Jews, among whom Jesus was born, had a fully documented history of advocating the pseudo-morality of groupism.”

    [ . . .]

    A contrast can be pointed up by recalling that Jesus found it necessary to advocate love for one’s fellow beings among the Jews. The Jews restrained individuals from killing the unscrupulous among themselves; instead, they gave an evolutionary preference to those “whited sepulchers” who used “legal” means – that is to say, group force – to destroy the individuals who were not legal-minded.

    The (German) way of life, based on individual sovereignty, did not propagate the unlovable. But it also did not propagate fierce fighters exclusively. There were always some who had no fighting temperament, who had a temperament only for gardening, poetry, music caring for animals, and such things. If they did not try to replace fair fights with word-control – aimed at underhanded scheming for group or “legal” dominance – they were usually shielded by someone ready to protect them, from challenges made by the overaggressive. This bred out the overaggressive at the same time it perpetuated the sensitive – those who lived under the protection of another’s shield Early “civilized” (Roman) observers remarked about the strangeness of such relationships.

    • Nick Dean's Gravatar Nick Dean
      August 18, 2017 - 2:42 pm | Permalink

      I’ll have to return to this to be clear about any stronger correspondence, but James Bowery, who posted for the longest time at majorityrights.com, often makes related points. He’s probably the most original and holistic thinker in WN as well as the smartest. Look him up if you haven’t already.

  31. Nick Dean's Gravatar Nick Dean
    August 18, 2017 - 2:28 pm | Permalink

    To-give-us-Asians,

    And Africans and Amerindians/Mestizos,

    trump.

  32. August 19, 2017 - 6:16 pm | Permalink

    Pete“Time magazine was subsequently accused of manipulating the photograph to make Simpson appear “darker” and “menacing”.”How silly…if Time really wanted to show how dark and menacing Simpson was they could have just featured a completely black cover and still would not have managed to convey the evil in this man’s heart.But i get it..kat-

  33. British's Gravatar British
    August 23, 2017 - 1:44 am | Permalink

    Sure Trump is under pressure to be politically correct because the US president is suppose to represent everybody which is the entire nation, even those wanting him assassinated (liberals). I think all the United States (Trump voters) want is that Donald Trump keep his promises he made to become president, which is to, build a wall with Mexico and Mexico’s money, enforce immigration law, penalize business leaving the country, penalize ‘sanctuary cities’ harboring criminals. But the president isn’t helping to counter-offense the ongoing war against whites by attacking whites and by them exercising their free speech especially being the mind-set of the police are already controlled and set to be aggravated toward whites, but really the president should try everything possible not to make it more possible for whites to express themselves being white is wrong and the entire internet is owned and operated by creepy liberal communist promoting anti-white views and the communist agenda.

    I remember black History year (year with a slash through it) month. Month, yeah month. The entire month we were suppose to be so appreciated to blacks for everything. Whites couldn’t get away with anything like this.
    I remember Donald Trump just oozing with confort , political correct words saying how much blacks are valued and how important black history year (slash) month- 31 days is.
    He originally wanted Ophey Winfrey vice president. A black girl from the Ghetto of Chicago trying to make ‘black big’ on local Chicago radio and television, someone liberal communist helped to chain a nation to white guilt and self destruction just what the communist wanted a political rally.
    Now she’s a billionaire and can fund black people to move beside you, and set up the military station.

  34. John Walton's Gravatar John Walton
    August 25, 2017 - 3:06 pm | Permalink

    “Republicans are incapable of learning this lesson.” C’mon, man. None so blind as those who lose AIPAC money if they see. We need to support campaign finance reform. Anything would be better than having a handful of billionaires call the tune.

Comments are closed.