The Elite Fantasy of Solving American Racial Tensions Through Intermarriage
For decades, American intellectuals and political strategists have searched for an exit ramp from the nation’s enduring racial divisions. Across ideological lines, a recurring cohort of elites—of predominantly Jewish extraction—have proposed interracial marriage as the ultimate solution for group conflict. Yet the history of this idea reveals sharp contradictions between utopian rhetoric, demographic reality, and the undeniable tendency of racial groups preferring to share intimacy with members of their own race.
Long before post-war commentators embraced interracial marriage as a strategy to alleviate racial tensions, early 20th-century anthropologists laid the conceptual groundwork. Columbia University anthropologist Franz Boas argued in his 1910 essay “The Real Race Problem” that gradual amalgamation of the White and Black populations would resolve the race problem. Decades later, anthropologist Ashley Montagu, born Israel Ehrenberg, defended race mixture in Man’s Most Dangerous Myth, which includes a chapter titled “The Creative Power of ‘Race’ Mixture.” Hannah Arendt, a Jewish political theorist born in Germany, reached a narrower conclusion in her Winter 1959 Dissent essay Reflections on Little Rock, condemning laws that ban mixed marriage and calling the right to marry whomever one wishes “an elementary human right.”
One of the most notorious postwar endorsements of amalgamation emerged from a personal literary dispute. In Norman Podhoretz’s own account, the Commentary editor proposed and commissioned a piece from famed Black author James Baldwin on the Black Muslims. Baldwin instead sold it to The New Yorker, which ran it on November 17, 1962 as “Letter from a Region in My Mind.” That essay became the bulk of The Fire Next Time. Over drinks, Podhoretz vented his anger and described his childhood in Brooklyn, where he says Black kids repeatedly beat up and robbed him. Baldwin whispered that he ought to “write all that down.” The result was “My Negro Problem—and Ours,” published in Commentary in February 1963. Podhoretz called White Americans “so twisted and sick in our feelings about Negroes” and wrote that “the wholesale merging of the two races is the most desirable alternative for everyone concerned.”
Podhoretz’s essay set off a firestorm among the chattering classes. Rarely had a Commentary article drawn more than a few letters, and 20 counted as extraordinary, yet this one drew more than 300. In a 2013 retrospective, Podhoretz noted that readers praised its “intellectual integrity,” “honesty,” and “courage,” but “hardly anyone agreed” with his endorsement of miscegenation. The most explicit endorsement among the published letters came from critic Hilton Kramer, who later became a prominent neoconservative. Kramer praised the essay’s “moral clarity” as “an entirely new beginning” for White liberals, argued that integration talk stopping short of miscegenation was “dishonest rhetoric,” and credited Podhoretz with placing miscegenation “as a socially desirable solution” in the foreground of debate.
Other readers dissented while praising its candor. Murray Hausknecht argued that the “special feeling about color” springs from institutionalized segregation, that desegregation would lead to more intermarriage and so quicken its erosion, and that Podhoretz offered an “individual cure of souls” to avoid the risks of desegregation. Psychologist Kenneth B. Clark, who agreed with “most of what Mr. Podhoretz says,” rejected the idea that miscegenation or intermarriage could solve the problem. He distinguished sexual exploitation from marriage between equals and argued that widespread intermarriage would signal the problem’s absence.
By the 1990s, arguments celebrating demographic blending resurfaced across the political spectrum. American Enterprise Institute neoconservative Ben Wattenberg cast America as a nation where generations of immigrants were mingling in his 1990 book The First Universal Nation. On PBS’s Think Tank, he later cited surging outmarriage, with Jewish rates climbing from about 5 percent to 50 percent, as evidence that America was creating “a first universal nation.” Nathan Glazer pressed that Black outmarriage remained far lower, at about 4 percent, and Commentary reviewer Louis Winnick judged that the book “fails to provide a persuasive or even sustained argument” for its thesis.
The fashion peaked when Time unveiled a computer-morphed cover woman in its November 18, 1993 special issue, “The New Face of America.” Editors wanted to “dramatize the impact of interethnic marriage,” and they presented her as a symbol of America’s multiethnic future, composed of 15 percent Anglo-Saxon, 17.5 percent Middle Eastern, 17.5 percent African, 7.5 percent Asian, 35 percent Southern European and 7.5 percent Hispanic ancestry. Novelist Danzy Senna later satirized the vogue for mixed ancestry in her 1998 essay The Mulatto Millennium, which opens “Strange to wake up and realize you’re in style.”
Public intellectuals soon adapted this blending motif to rival ideological agendas. In his 1995 book The Next American Nation, liberal nationalist Michael Lind called for a transracial melting pot in which intermarriage dissolved the lines of color, national origin and religion, as one review put it. In a 1998 New York Times Magazine essay, he warned that the melting pot could yield a majority of “hard-to-differentiate” beige Americans alongside a Black minority left out once again, according to a National Academies report.
Conservative commentators, by contrast, invoked intermarriage in arguments against race-conscious policy. AEI research fellow Dinesh D’Souza wrote in his 1995 book The End of Racism that “old racial categories are rapidly becoming obsolete,” mainly because of intermarriage. In a 1996 New York Times Magazine essay, contrarian critic Stanley Crouch speculated that growing numbers of mixed-race Americans would erode race as a basis for “special-interest power.” In a July 1, 1997 letter to the Office of Management and Budget, House Speaker Newt Gingrich endorsed a multiracial Census option, writing that “simply being American should be enough,” and he testified at a House hearing on July 25.
Even as 1990s pundits proclaimed the end of race, skeptics challenged that optimism. Writing in Slate in 1996, Eric Liu observed that Podhoretz’s essay, regarded as bizarre at the time, looked like prophecy 33 years later. He added that the intermarriage boom had not yet brought the racial harmony Podhoretz longed for, and he warned that “Subverting racial labels is not the same as subverting racism.” Similar critiques emerged on the right. Commentary’s Dan Seligman faulted Richard Rodriguez’s brown thesis as radically undeveloped. Immigration restrictionist Peter Brimelow argued in his 1995 book Alien Nation that the American nation has a specific ethnic core, and David Gordon, reviewing the book in the Mises Review, called Wattenberg’s universal nation “a contradiction in terms.”
The sharpest repudiation came from Podhoretz himself. After a 1993 postscript to a reprint in the anthology Blacks and Jews, he published a 50-year retrospective in Commentary in May 2013 admitting he had been “wrong to think that miscegenation could ever result in the elimination of color-consciousness.” He conceded that Ralph Ellison was right to fault his dismissive attitude toward Black culture. He named out of wedlock births as the root cause of Black disadvantage. He also argued that Barack Obama’s presidency, though Obama is a product of miscegenation, had heightened rather than eased American consciousness of color.
Nevertheless, variations of the blending thesis persisted into the 2010s and 2020s. In a June 2013 column, New York Times neoconservative David Brooks predicted that Americans would soon become “a nation of mutts,” and he defended the word choice to the Times public editor after readers objected. Noah Smith built directly on Brooks’s piece in a blog post, arguing that Americans would need to create an “American” ethnicity, starting with a common language and intermarriage. Political scientist Eric Kaufmann offered a twist aimed at conservatives in his 2018 book Whiteshift. He argued that White majorities would absorb newcomers through intermarriage while remaining oriented around “existing myths of descent, symbols and traditions,” a path he hoped would let conservatives see the change as positive.
Empirical data complicates the case for widespread race mixing. A 2017 Pew study marking 50 years since Loving v. Virginia found that 17 percent of 2015 newlyweds married across racial or ethnic lines, up from 3 percent in 1967. The rate reached 29 percent for Asian newlyweds, 27 percent for Hispanic newlyweds, 18 percent for Black newlyweds and 11 percent for White newlyweds. Among intermarried 2015 newlyweds, White and Hispanic couples made up 42 percent, followed by White and Asian couples at 15 percent, White and multiracial couples at 12 percent and White and Black couples at 11 percent, according to a Pew follow up poll.
By 2024, a Pew chart of American Community Survey data showed outmarriage at 32 percent for both Hispanic and Asian newlyweds, 25 percent for Black newlyweds and 16 percent for White newlyweds. Yet Census Bureau tables for 2023 recorded roughly 677,000 non-Hispanic Black and White married couples, just 1.1 percent of opposite sex married family groups. Of those, 409,000 paired a Black husband with a White wife and 268,000 paired a White husband with a Black wife. Nearly half, or 47.4 percent, lived with their own children under 18. A study by sociologists Zhenchao Qian and Daniel Lichter in the Journal of Marriage and Family used American Community Survey data from 2008 to 2017. It found that 15.5 percent of Black husband and White wife couples married within the past five years had a birth in the past year, versus 12.8 percent of White husband and Black wife couples.
In the end, as Podhoretz himself recognized after 50 years, romantic patterns cannot dissolve deep-seated racial fault lines by simple decree.
José Niño is a writer based in Charlotte, North Carolina. You can contact him via Facebook and Twitter. Subscribe to his Substack newsletter by visiting “Jose Nino Unfiltered” on Substack.com





Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!