Yet another exchange with Nathan Cofnas

Nathan Cofnas has replied to my critique of his comments on Ed Dutton (see list of my three previous exchanges with Cofnas in the References section; I realize this is getting confusing).

There is nothing new here. Again, there is the tendency to ignore critical passages of Culture of Critique (CofC) as well as my previous replies. And once again, as throughout this exchange, he fails to grasp the theoretical structure of CofC. As a result, his attempts at refutation typically consist of points that, even when true (e.g., contemporary rates of Jewish intermarriage are quite high), are irrelevant to a proper critique of CofC. There is indeed a strong empirical basis to CofC. But to refute it, fundamentally one would have to dispute the Jewish identifications and sense of pursuing Jewish interests among the key figures.

To continue, please go to Research Gate.

13 replies
  1. James Bowery
    James Bowery says:

    Guys like this are sacrificial troops in the war of discourse. Such a indefatigable nonsense is guaranteed to damage any real academic reputation. For those in disreputable fields, however — especially those who are not leading figures, such as Cofnas — they’re already basically bereft of reputation. All they have is a credential and position that, being in a disreputable field such as social research, is going to be theirs no matter how much they embarrass themselves before the world of serious scholars.

    • Carolyn Yeager
      Carolyn Yeager says:

      In truth, most of the arguments of “serious scholars” are in-group diversions and self-glorifications that do not advance human understanding one whit. Plain common sense confrontations are more effective and go farther in reaching the largest audience than do academically-approved name-dropping ‘arguments’ among PhDs.

    • Chetley V
      Chetley V says:

      Prof. MacDonald is being attacked now because his trilogy has broken through the ceiling of insouciance of a now worried West. The growing popularity of CofC and its supporting prior volumes is perceived as a serious threat. I hope he will take the challenge the way D.J.T. does: First they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. If he is like Trump, I’d say MacDonald is in for a lot of joyful stress. Rhetorik greift an.

  2. Right man for the job
    Right man for the job says:

    If I wrote to Cofnas, my epistle would be entitled “T H E LAST TIME.”

    I learned long ago never to engage with the Jew in conversation or debate unless there is a reciprocity of respect. Most of them live for shock value, insult, denigration, incivility, rudeness, effrontery, impudence, arrogance…and it is seldom possible to even insult them. They thrive on contention and confrontation. They are all Don Rickles, Jerry Springers, Jack E. Leonards, Sarah Silvermans and Howard Sterns.

    Even when they “convert” to Christianity, it is evident that Holy Water does not change their DNA.

    • Richard B
      Richard B says:

      One of the best comments I’ve ever read about Jews. Spot on.

      And because it’s so true it means that they and not Whites are the real cancer of the human history. Which makes Susan Sontag’s comment a typical bit of ethnic projection. Nietzsche didn’t refer to them as the world’s greatest haters for nothing. Which would make their accusations of Hate Speech yet another example of projection and their Hate Speech laws a so far successful attempt at self-protection.

      Speaking of Nietzsche, for anyone out there who has never read his On The Genealogy of Morals, I highly recommend it. If you want to thumb through it you might want to check out the First Essay, Aphorism 7, and the Third Essay, Aphorism 14. The end of that essay speaks to a challenge we’re all facing. And it’s our responsibility to meet that challenge better than anyone else. To the extent we don’t we’re doomed. Because it’s exactly on this point that many of our finest are simply falling through the cracks.

  3. Adelf Hitlaird
    Adelf Hitlaird says:

    What… a jew failing to address the salient points of a logical, well reasoned argument? Imagine my shock!

  4. Mihir Atrekar
    Mihir Atrekar says:

    Dr. MacDonald, do you hate minorities and want them booted out from Europe and the US, or do you see a way to integrate and keep some?

  5. Earl Oill
    Earl Oill says:

    In “One More Time” McDonald appears to say that Jews are ‘adapted’ to undermining a host culture only in that they are smart and good at networking. If ‘adapted’ is meant as ‘genetically adapted’ then what is the evidence that they are adapted for efficient networking? Anyway, I thought he was saying something more specific, e.g. that they were adapted to favor their group effectively when under the constraint of minority status.

  6. Ed
    Ed says:

    Yes, when debating Jews and (((liberals)))/supporters of Jews, they will always refuse to acknowledge/recognize the points they cannot argue or refute that I present and continue on trying to find some small point they can refute. When they ultimately FAIL, thanks to all the knowledge passed by people like MacDonald and David Duke that have helped make me a goyim that knows, they either report me, delete the whole thread, or both!

    Doth this Jew protest too much? It reminds me of the McCain seemingly endless and over blown funeral where we saw all of the nations complicit criminals come together in an attempt to affirm the lies they and the media have told us now for decades in the minds of the American people.

    Point out how this Jew intentionally avoids admitting/confirming what you are right about as he continues to try and find some spin that will convince the goyim you are wrong! Obviously the Jews revisiting this after all these years shows that something has happened that has them worried. Maybe it is all the people spreading the brief “Culture of Critique for Normies” videos all over social media that has the Jews in such a panic. Me thinks there is a connection to have Jew Google searches that show Jews DENYING you findings.

    As always, thank you for all of you hard work and dedication. You are an amazing teacher and your work is making it that much easier for goyim to KNOW! Happy Labor Day!

Comments are closed.