Guide to Kulchur: “It’s not the Jews, stupid!”

Editor’s note: The following article, by Guide To Kulchur, was in response to my fundraising appeal of a couple days a ago and appeared on his website. Framed in terms of competing interests, it is an eloquent statement and concludes with an appeal to  support his website. One thing we absolutely know about Jews is that they are very generous in funding their causes. The same cannot be said of the pro-White movement.
34 replies
  1. Tim Folke
    Tim Folke says:

    Excellent wake up call.

    Perhaps it can be summed up in the old saying that ‘When you point the finger of accusation at others, the other three fingers are pointing back at the real problem’.

    • moneytalks
      moneytalks says:

      …” the real problem “…

      Are you referring to the ageless problem of
      an inveterate ignorance of humanity ? ;
      in particular , a widespread and deep ignorance of Nordics
      about the existential threat against them ?

      (( Nordics are also known as :

      Whites / Aryans /

      Euroman / Europeans / Indo-Europeans /

      Caucasians / Occidentals /

      [ and a some other unspecified smaller predominantly Nordic populations scattered around the world ] )) .

  2. Karl Haemers
    Karl Haemers says:

    Ok sure. Fair enough.
    But it’s not that simple is it? Some people are afraid to support “the right” because they could lose their jobs, face social ostracism, or go to prison like those who protested at the capital on 1/6. People in Canada supported the trucker convoy, and then had their bank accounts closed and faced fines. A white man uses a legal firearm to defend himself and his wife from a violent black criminal, and the white man goes to prison while the black criminals go free under Soros DAs. While TOO gets deplatformed and de-monetized, BLM gets $millions in corporate donations, government grants and deluded citizen contributions. Trump’s Jews allowed him to mobilize the white right in 2016, but then had him alienate them in 2020, suppressing white right voter turnout, and throwing the election even beyond any vote fraud.

    But okay, sure. Fair enough. The last people who really advocated their own cause against the Jews were the National Socialist Germans. They were highly successful for a while, but then we know what happened. Perhaps people are afraid to repeat that catastrophe.

    Maybe what the white right needs more than enthusiasm or caring or engagement is courage. So let’s start with Legal Defense Funds. James Fields should have had a large legal fund and lawyer team representing him. The white right abandons its own out of fear of association. Courage!

    • Carolyn Yeager
      Carolyn Yeager says:

      Thanks Karl, for having the courage and sense to offer a different perspective, or view, of the “giving” matter. I give plenty to my people’s causes, to what I see as most important to me, but not to TOO. TOO doesn’t even get 20th Century history right, according to many Whites. If we can’t agree on that, what can we agree on?

      So should I not presume to comment here, if I’m not paying for the privilege? When I suggested that once, way back, I was roundly admonished by the moderator (who does like to get in on the act). And I certainly do contribute in “other ways” and always have since I got on the Internet. I also think I write “good comments” with a lot of meat on the bones, which are a valuable contribution to any site.

      So I just think it was a mistake to publish that particular article, which was an indirect slam at your own readers. The goal should be greater readership, not collecting donations to pay your writers more in the hope (must be) of attracting better quality material. I think that’s where the pro-White movement falls down. It’s not just cowardice, but high quality thinking and ability to express it, no holds barred.

      Hey, whatever happened to Andrew Joyce?

      • Pierre de Craon
        Pierre de Craon says:

        I agree with you and Karl Haemers. On October 10, I also posted a comment with a somewhat different perspective. The Moderator was less tolerant of my disagreement, however, despite the fact that it was expressed with no trace of disrespect. In short, he suppressed my comment.

        Kevin MacDonald is well known to be a man who has never called for the suppression of disagreement. Where appropriate, he meets it head on. I wonder, therefore, whether he is aware of how extraordinarily arbitrary the behavior of some of his moderators is.

        • Emicho
          Emicho says:

          I’m surprised at you two getting comments suppressed.
          I write all sorts of half-assed nonsense and I’ve only been censored once, correctly, when I was bitching too much like a girl.
          Don’t get me wrong, I whole-heartedly endorse and truly believe everything I write.
          But to be really honest, Mr MacDonald got in touch with me personally and explained he worried the site was a bit too highfaluting for a mass readership, and could you please lower the intellectual tone with whatever is on your mind, for the purposes of making the commenters like yourselves feel better about the quality stuff you produce.
          So when the Big Man asks a favour, you take it as a sacred order, hence the many Emicho comments we all know and love.
          I hope that clears things up for anyone wondering why such an august magazine is infested with the out-of-context ramblings of an uneducated, semi-illiterate Euro-trash peasant.

          • Carolyn Yeager
            Carolyn Yeager says:

            “I write all sorts of half-assed nonsense and I’ve only been censored once,”

            I’ve noticed that. Nice of you to bring it up so I can finally say it too. You seem to be a favorite of the moderator (who I think is always the same guy – that’s why it’s such a slow process). Who can explain it? I find it mystifying.

    • Roland Maruska
      Roland Maruska says:

      Dear Sir:

      Excellent post. And as for the poor people of Germany, look at what their fellow (American) whites did to them in WW11. By the way, do you read Culture Wars magazine? There have been a number of issues exposing the exaggerations of the Jewish holocaust industry, the vindictiveness of America and England, and the murderous post-war holocaust against German POWs of General Eisenhower, who remained a liberal until the Dulles brothers got hold of him in the 1950s.

      Roland Maruska

    • Michael Fury
      Michael Fury says:

      Their love for their imperiled heritage

      The Enemy announced was “hate”, and in his rage

      Demanded all must hate their hate and all

      Must hate without exception any soul

      Unwise enough to show them sympathy

      Or face the trials of his antipathy,

      From social exile to the heavy threat

      Of laws he promised soon to legislate

      Against the merest overheard expression

      In defiance of his anti-white suppression.

  3. Dixie Serb
    Dixie Serb says:

    I was saying that years ago. Jews never felt comfortable in the majority white Christian countries so the open societies of the Liberal Democracy opened the doors for their ascend to power. In the meantime for the longest the Right’s mantra (at least in the U.S.) was: “We just want to be left alone” and even less helpful: “Don’t send your kids to college.”

  4. Emicho
    Emicho says:

    Yeah but is there an actual reason rich white people don’t support the white cause, which amounts to supporting poor white people? Besides inertia, or whatever? For 99% of rich white people, they aren’t noble, their origins are among the poor white masses they’ve abandoned, and it’s in their own interests to help in other ways.
    Conservative Inc has been a racket for . . . actually I’m not aware it’s ever not been a racket. Same for MAGA, they bring in the dough. What do they do that our people don’t?
    Yes, shame these rich whites, I just can’t help thinking there must be something else going on.
    I’m glad Mr Kultur man let me off-the-hook, our problems aren’t in our stars or in the Jews, but ourselves.
    True ‘dat.

  5. Samoan
    Samoan says:

    There are some white advocates like NSC 131 and others that are actually organizing in person and forming protests. We need more of that.

    One thing I can’t stand on the right is that every call to organize is met with accusations of being a fed which feels more like a cop out each time. If you care about something you should devote time and resources to it. Otherwise your just larping behind a keyboard. NSC 131 meets in masks to conceal their identities and makes videos showing the impact they’re making in their protests. We need more of THAT.

  6. Franklin Ryckaert
    Franklin Ryckaert says:

    There are more than one billion Whites in the world, but only some 15 million Jews. Still the Jews are winning in their battle against us. There must be a reason…

      • Emicho
        Emicho says:

        Good point.

        Especially white women/beta males, then add grifters, and most young people who only know anti-white hatred the Jewish mass media has programmed into them.
        Then you have any white with a little money, who are beholden to Jews as going against them would entail losing everything they value.
        It doesn’t leave a great amount left, sure, more than there are Jews, perhaps, but not by much, and all by definition without any power.
        And the traitor whites described above are suppressing us before Jews even get to work on our folks.

        If we didn’t have Jesus Christ on our side, or, for our pagan white nationalist brothers, Truth, there really wouldn’t be much reason for hope.

      • Carolyn Yeager
        Carolyn Yeager says:

        That’s it! You said it beautifully. Emicho should have stopped with his first two words.

        As is known, I’ve always (almost) expressed that “White” may be inclusive but doesn’t have any power. It doesn’t reach people where it needs to. It doesn’t motivate or move the emotional self, which is where our power center is.

        When it comes to big movements, reasoning alone has proven not to be enough.

        • moneytalks
          moneytalks says:

          Emotion motivates and logic guides .

          Big mistake to abandon valid logics
          to unguided or misguided emotions as is often done by those whom believe that
          “reason is the slave of emotion”;
          since valid logics are enslaved to seeking the actual truth and not just associated emotions coincidental to it .

  7. moneytalks
    moneytalks says:

    ” It means you’re in control of your destiny.”

    USA Nordics are predominantly at least nominal Christians
    where Christianity , in addition to having profound and powerful affects on thinking processes , is dogmatic about faith in the belief
    that God is really in control of human destiny — “your destiny”.

    Furthermore , most USA Nordics
    have never known and still do not know
    about the JQ ;
    and the jewmasterss like it that way and intend to keep it that way .

    Moreover ,
    Christianity itself
    ( that is , by far most Christians themselves )
    since no later than WW2
    has facilitated the jewish sponsored and/or acquiescence of nearly total deracination or dis-enculturation of Westernworld , including also the USA , Nordics whom are notoriously politicly retarded
    ( not an assertion about their relatively high average IQ )
    as an ineluctable result ,
    where neither jews nor Nordics are to blame for it ,
    of more than ten thousand years prior to WW2
    of living predominantly rural lifestyles
    which are normally nonpolitical and commensurately anti-intellectual .

    • Pika Chu
      Pika Chu says:

      Furthermore , most USA Nordics
      have never known and still do not know
      about the JQ ;
      and the jewmasterss like it that way and intend to keep it that way .

      Not anymore now that Kanye West has been cancelled.

  8. Dan
    Dan says:

    Unfortunately, everything this man said is accurate. If we are to survive as a people we need to contribute to the cause. I will be mailing funds this afternoon.

  9. Marcus Baskett
    Marcus Baskett says:

    “Prof. MacDonald has been talking for decades about how Jews are advancing Jewish interests at the expense of Europeans. He has described exactly in detail how this is done — through well-funded and well-organized lobby groups and intellectual movements.

    Still, it hasn’t occurred to wealthy white people that they need to be serious about supporting operations advancing white interests…

    Isn’t that astonishing?”

    Not when “Jewish interests” IS to subjugate (at best) the gentile white race and bald face deny the obvious.

    “Of course you have to be cautious about who to support. You can’t be careless about throwing money around.”

    I think that’s an attitude only Jews have because 1. It’s self contradicting. 2. It’s arrogant, condescending unsolicited and dogmatic.

    “ But with regard to someone like Prof. MacDonald… someone who brings unquestionable value to the table… someone who is obviously not involved for reasons of ego or self-aggrandizement… someone who has proven his worth over decades… there should be no question.

    It’s a disgrace that we have wealthy people who supposedly agree with us, but Kevin is struggling to keep his operation going after all these years.

    If The Occidental Observer doesn’t have a reasonable budget, it’s only because people on the Right don’t bother supporting it.

    No one else can be blamed.”

    No. actually Jews are to blame the most because of the terror they instill into peoples minds in our culture. Gaslighting the entire nation with the twisted self contradictory narrative of being “a persecuted people” when it’s obvious the most persecution to occur throughout history has come FROM the Jews. Not to them.
    Furthermore; It sucks the we have to have any literature on this subject and situation nobody sets out to become an “antisemite” and I’m sure professor MacDonald would rather be spending his valuable time enjoying his life but the Jews and only the Jews have made his and many others life situations into a nightmare for ringing the bell about OUR situation.

    “It’s Convenient to blame the Jews:”
    No. It’s actually mind boggling confusing and a terrifyingly weird experience to confront Jews face on or even just talk honestly between and/or amongst non-Jews about a very real problem – namely being oppressed by the one and only “hate group” allowed by our centers of justice to thrive in their open hate for white gentile males – while being constantly under the threats of being mobbed…………………
    Again no… it’s actually going along letting Jews bully us around contemptuously that is convenient
    again having to deal with the rain of wrath and slander of blowing the whistle on the Jews is ANYTHING but convenient not to mention carrying around the knowledge you have and the terror of not having anyone to talk to about it and no where to go as a point of authority that specifically deals with protection for white gentiles from Jewish hostility and injustice on any and all levels under the US constitution and as it relates to the distinctly single citizen USA citizen(s).

    On one hand you patronizingly smooch up to PKM while calling out his followers with derogatory names then to go on claiming that it’s just convenient to blame the Jews – so, which one is it??

    I could go on but I don’t have the time to completely pick apart such an unmastery of modern Jewish “excrement art” Your diatribe “article “ is merely a bag of confusing word salad contemptuous self contradictory latent despair.

    • Michael Fury
      Michael Fury says:

      They came of age the heirs of ruin,

      When remnants of the West were carrion

      To a ravening madness, a fear whose name

      Their fathers knew but feared remember, for shame

      Had so unmanned them, and degradations

      By degrees for generations

      The Enemy bred them to embrace and cherish.

      The virtues of their forebears so would perish,

      And with them any memory of their worth

      As nations or the race from whom came forth

      A civilization peerless and sublime.

      To this end the Enemy over time

      By sophistry, by trickery and theft

      Had sabotaged their minds, until bereft

      Of truth the sons of Europe were slaves

      Most base, slaves who swore on their lives

      They were free….

  10. Nick
    Nick says:

    I don’t think it is very wise to appeal a fundraiser while simultaneously calling those who you wish to support you lazy and stingy.

  11. Pierre de Craon
    Pierre de Craon says:

    A second attempt at expressing disagreement with “approved” opinion. Will this one fall victim to “moderation,” too?

    Framed in terms of competing interests, [the article in Guide to Kulchur] is an eloquent statement and concludes with an appeal to support his website.

    The article does indeed conclude “with an appeal to support his website.” On that much we agree. As for the rest, Kevin, I see an article characterized by glibness and speciousness rather than eloquence. Moreover, with regard to your body of work, I see in it more than a suggestion of disdain veiled with faint praise.

    How anyone with a trace of integrity can imply that what Jews do and advocate involves as little culpability as the kick of a goat is beyond me. Avoiding the impact of a goat’s kick is child’s play. Avoiding the impact of the Jewish power structure’s kick might necessitate permanent relocation to Pitcairn Island.

      • Pierre de Craon
        Pierre de Craon says:

        That’s good to know, Kevin. I sincerely hope that others read the essay as you do rather than as I did.

        • Nail
          Nail says:

          I agree with you and read it with frustration and rage, as a fan of Frodi’s Decameron series, and his general presence and efforts, since 2020.

          >>Those who have a below-average income should contribute in other ways, while those who have money should contribute money.

          How should we, when those with money know they risk their bank account being closed and those without know they won’t ever get a promotion or potential for higher status/salary work if they speak out?

          >>But it should be a sobering thought. It means you’re in control of your destiny.

          Yes, our destiny to live not merely zero, but negative status lives, inorganically made into pariahs. They’ve been doing this *SINCE CHARLES LINDBERGH*. How entrenched in your reluctance (early brainwashing slogans having their intended effect?) to accept that this is really happening to us, and that we know who are doing it?

          The ADL put Hoffman (founder of reddit) on one of thier boards after harassing him with hit job journalist Jew Andrew Marantz, and sent intimidating “open letters” to Jack Dorsey (twitter). The ADL controls the trusted flaggers on youtube which can designate whatever it wants removed as hate. We, the content creators and seminar organizers, cannot break through due to *Jewish control over social media.* 2015-2016 and the ensuing Jewish censorship campaign, presently successful and active, showed this.

          Frodi, have you read Andrew Joyce’s article about the psychological warfare techniques created by Paul Lazarsfeld? Who else did this, and with what underlying motivation?

          The average white is in a fog of war they’re not even aware of and have been groomed to think the main source of this fog are actually victims and it’s all a conspiracy. And you blame them instead of those who are waging this covert cold war against them?

Comments are closed.