Elon Musk on immigration, remigration, White fertility and the traitors among us

This is by Jamelle Bouie, a Black NYTimes columnist. So, not surprising. But Musk is clearly the most mainstream voice articulating anti-immigration, pro-remigration, pro-White fertility views, with a healthy dose of condemning the traitors among us. In short, Musk’s views are the views articulated here, except that we attempt to show clearly how the disaster condemned by Musk came about. And we identify the traitors.  The left would love to shut him up, free speech be damned. Bouie of course hates Musk and tries to connect him to William Pierce’s The Turner Diaries. The left cannot tolerate even one voice articulating these ideas because they know that the fears of White dispossession are solidly based and that they resonate among millions of White people.

Why Do We Tolerate Elon Musk’s Racist Commentary?

Elon Musk standing before white stars on a blue backdrop.
Credit…Ioulex for The New York Times
Jamelle Bouie

“The Turner Diaries” is a work of white supremacist agitprop. It purports to be the diary of a neo-Nazi militant, Earl Turner, who is working to overthrow the United States government — or as the book calls it, “the System” — through a group called “the Organization.” Turner castigates “the System” for promoting integration, encouraging nonwhite immigration and placing Jewish people, Black Americans and other minorities in positions of authority over whites.

Among other atrocities, the novel describes nuclear attacks on predominantly Black cities, a Holocaust of Jewish Americans, the total ethnic cleansing of California, the subjugation of women and the “Day of the Rope” — a mass public lynching of white people deemed “race traitors” for their relationships with nonwhites. The book’s epilogue describes a future after the “Great Revolution” in which the former United States is now an all-white, utopian garrison state led by the Organization, which went on to export its revolution and exterminate nonwhites worldwide.

The white power movement in the United States, notes the historian Augusta Dell’Omo in “Saving Apartheid: White Internationalism at the End of the Cold War,” “looked to white southern Africa for inspiration as it planned for the coming ‘race war.’” This apocalyptic fantasy of racial conflict in places such as Zimbabwe and South Africa shaped “The Turner Diaries.” And in turn the novel, first serialized in the pages of a white nationalist periodical in 1975 and then published as a stand-alone volume in 1978, became a touchstone for the American and global far right.

“The Order,” a white supremacist terrorist group responsible for three killings, including the murder of the Denver talk-radio host Alan Berg, took its name from the book. And Timothy McVeigh, who bombed the Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City, killing 168 people, carried passages from the book on his person and once sold the book at gun shows.

The ideas, images and language of “The Turner Diaries” have long since entered the gestalt of far-right ideology. The book hovers there even when it isn’t mentioned. In his manifesto, for example, Dylann Roof — who murdered nine people at the Mother Emanuel Church in Charleston, S.C. — frames himself as a martyr and calls on white Americans to fight a race war against Black people.

Today, you don’t have to look far or dig deep to see the ambient influence of “The Turner Diaries” on the far right. You need just to spend a little time in the online world of the richest man on the planet, Elon Musk (although to be clear there is no direct evidence that Musk has read the book).

The Musk of the mainstream media is an enthusiastic, if awkward, technologist, industrialist and would-be government reformer, as seen in his now-defunct Department of Government Efficiency. But Musk spends much of his time on X, his social media website, where he amplifies far-right accounts and shares his own white nationalist, anti-immigrant politics for all the world to see.

Over the past month in particular, he has adopted the imagery of a recent film, “Citizen Vigilante,” in which the actor Armie Hammer spends the run time playing a Charles Bronson-esque character who targets alleged criminals, framed mostly as Arab and African migrants. Musk uses that imagery to state his views about what must be done to save Western civilization.

“Yes,” replied Musk to an image of a gun-toting Hammer clad in black with the caption, “First the traitors then the invaders.” He also shared a post from a different user who explained that the point of “Citizen Vigilante,” in which the Hammer character “spends the first half of the movie murdering white people not migrants,” is that you must “always hang a traitor before you hang an enemy.” Musk repeated this several times, including in a post that simply said, “Traitors before invaders.”

Last week, Musk again posted that we must “Deal with traitors before invaders” and then said a few days later that “Anyone who opposes remigration is a traitor.”

Remigration” is the call, from far-right European political parties, to forcibly remove nonwhite citizens to their supposed countries of origin, regardless of whether they are immigrants or native-born. It is essentially a form of ethnic cleansing and it is envisioned as a response to the supposed “Great Replacement” of white Europeans with nonwhites, an idea originating from a different work of far-right fiction, “The Camp of the Saints,” published in 1973.

As Musk sees it, opponents of remigration are traitors to “the West.” And as “traitors” their proper fate, according to the logic of his posts, is to be killed as punishment for their role in the demographic transformation of majority-white nations and, presumably, as a warning to those who might pollute the national bloodstream by welcoming nonwhites into their lives and into the country.

Musk’s preoccupation with demographic “traitors” flows directly from his obsession with population collapse, which he frames in terms of shrinking European and white American birthrates. “White people are a rapidly diminishing minority of the global population,” Musk wrote in September 2025. “Low birth rate,” he later said, “is the number one threat to the West followed closely by migration. There will be no West if this continues.”

One might even see his destruction of the United States Agency for International Development — responsible, so far, for an estimated 700,000 deaths worldwide — as consistent with his concern with falling white birthrates relative to those in places such as sub-Saharan Africa, where U.S.A.I.D. was active. After all, one way to secure a future for Western children, in this zero-sum view of the world, would be to starve African ones.

Musk, it should be said, insists that no one has died because of his cuts.

In a recent interview with The Economist, Musk denied that he was a racist, even as he defended his far-right views of immigration. “If you have a large and growing, rapidly growing group of people whose beliefs are antithetical to Western beliefs, at some point, there will be a reckoning,” he said.

But those views, as we see, are indistinguishable from what you would find in “The Turner Diaries.” With hundreds of millions of followers on a platform he personally controls, Musk stands as the most prominent purveyor of far-right and ultranationalistic rhetoric in the world. This is the same Musk who is also busy leveraging his vast wealth to shape that same world in his own image.

And what is that image?

As Quinn Slobodian and Ben Tarnoff show in their book “Muskism: A Guide for the Perplexed,” an important part of Musk’s vision is to see the world as a compound, where “the horizons of humankind” are shrunk “into the defense of white fertility.” This in turn is tied to a larger effort to liberate humanity from the “woke mind virus” that Musk sees as a self-destructive tendency responsible for the “empathy” that has led Western nations to open their societies to others.

This too is little more than a restatement of themes and ideas found in “The Turner Diaries,” where the titular character believes that whites have been corrupted by a “Jewish-liberal-democratic-egalitarian plague.” Slobodian and Tarnoff observe that these views are also downstream of Musk’s upbringing in South Africa, where apartheid leaders fretted over birthrates and the future of white society.

Musk’s virulent racism and vicious, disturbing views are no secret. He does not hide them. They sit in plain view, easily accessible on the social media website he owns, where he does everything he can to promote similarly far-right and white supremacist ideas.

If there is a question to ask, then, it is this: Why does Musk get a pass? Why do politicians, journalists and commentators treat his far-right racist radicalism as a sideshow rather than the core of his political, ideological and industrial project, seen in everything from his deep support for Donald Trump in the United States and Restore Britain in Britain to his decision to construct a massive pollution-generating data center in predominantly Black Memphis, Tenn.

Musk spends a large part of his free time fomenting violence and spreading the same hateful ideology that motivated some of the deadliest shootings and attacks ever to happen on American soil. It is that fact, and not the cars he builds or the rockets he launches, that ought to define his place in public life.

20 replies
  1. Englishman
    Englishman says:

    Money where your mouth is, Muskie!
    “One per cent of one day’s profit from a US oil company could finance a national revolution” (Mosley).
    So much of my country has been sold off to private equity in America that $$ in the right direction would be welcome.

  2. Let us read Kevin MacDonald not Andrew MacDonald
    Let us read Kevin MacDonald not Andrew MacDonald says:

    Tbh I think that Turner Diaries is a stupid book. Unhelpful for white survival. Instead of doing sth productive for ourselves and our race, we end up dreaming about harming others. Not a way to win.

    • Nicholas Seaman
      Nicholas Seaman says:

      On Pierce’s impact in terms of human life, read J.M. Berger, “The Turner Legacy”, on-line. He always seemed to me to have a charmed life, kept by the establishment as a bogey-man. Same with John Tyndall in the UK who lived in the center of the Jewish suburbs of Hove in Sussex.

  3. Alex
    Alex says:

    Muskie, a crypto-Jew and descendant of Randlords, Jews who destroyed S. Africa, is most emphatically not a friend.

      • Alex
        Alex says:

        “He is Jewish by bloodline. His grandmother from his mother’s side is Jewish. Search his grandmother: Winnifred Josephine “Wyn” Fletcher. This means Elon’s mother is Jewish and he is also technically Jewish.” – Tom 5G on Quora.

        So, who is able to research Muskie’s family tree? I am not a genealogist so I can get this far, no further.

        BTW in Jewish circles, you are Jewish if you have a Jewish maternal grandmother.

      • Nicholas Seaman
        Nicholas Seaman says:

        Haldeman is a European not Jewish surname. Elon is Hebrew for oak tree, but Dutch and Swiss Protestants sometimes give their kids names of Jewish origin; Noah is sadly quite fashionable today. Joseph Goebbels was not a Jew.
        In any case, why measure a gift horse by its muzzle? An unconditional donation to white nationalists would be welcome

        • Alfonsius Juggernaut
          Alfonsius Juggernaut says:

          As always, we’re all grateful for Nicholas’ invaluable opinion on everything and everyone.

  4. Frank
    Frank says:

    💯x💯x💯x💯
    on Turner Diaries.

    “Capitol Hill is israeli occupied territory” was all it took, and Pat Buchanan disappeared forever.

    How did, as commenters have remarked, William Pierce get ANY sunlight, whatsoever?

    bc they wanted the message to get out

    They want, NEED you to ‘do a violence.’ T.D. was nothing but a call to sit back, gather 35k rds of 5.56, and wait for the putsch to begin.

    What people need to do is the opposite, go out and talk to people, organize- maybe on the periphery,, but to actually do something other than post on Gab.

    Musk is amplifying anything but jews.
    He’d say to keep midgets as pets to keep the attention off the chosenites and their wanton, global killing.

    Don’t fall for it

    • Nicholas Seaman
      Nicholas Seaman says:

      Musk talked reasonable sense on Gaza in November 2023. However, Netanyahu has called him a “great friend of Israel”. Maybe, “business is business”, after all. X marks the (Yellow) Spot.

      • Alfonsius Juggernaut
        Alfonsius Juggernaut says:

        Less is often more, but more is often less, too. Sometimes, even “nothing” is actually more than nothing at all. All of us here know that, and we can already sense it coming. I’m speaking here on behalf of everyone involved. Or let’s say, “those affected.” Many chairs are also just a chair. In many ways, however, the most hereditary trait may be the least significant one.

  5. John
    John says:

    Musk Jewish or not…
    In the war against the alien-invasion in the lands of the whites, about everything is allowed, and one should not be too picky and pussy about the various parties in the fight, as it leads to fragmentation. I don’t like many of them, but the existence of whites and white culture is at stake, it is an existential issue.

  6. Wizard of Zog
    Wizard of Zog says:

    A POSSIBLE SCENARIO?

    EM (a trillionaire): Would you white nationalists like $500,000 towards your campaign to restore Europe and promote non-European re-migration?
    WN COALITION: You are a sub-human joo.
    EM: Yes or no?
    WNC: We don’t take dirty donations from well-poisoning baby-killers.
    EM: No strings attached.
    WNC: Shekels from sheeny shysters? Get lost, you crypto-kike! And don’t darken the internet with your “free speech” scam ever again. We can smell you from here. You will be first when the Accounting Takes Place, and we finish the job Hitler failed to start.
    EM: Second thoughts, with people like you around, I might just as well give it to the ADL.
    WNC: Proves our point, so go ahead.
    ADL: Thanks, folks.

  7. StopWhiteGenocide
    StopWhiteGenocide says:

    One could cherry-pick quotes to paint Musk as a vehement anti-racist as well.

    It’s not surprising that powerful people are now talking about low birthrates. This fits with their installment of Trump in 2024. They’ve achieved their goal—America is minority White. Now their focus shifts to muh economy, and muh economy needs babies.

    Musk recently said “Anyone who doesn’t love America is a traitor and beneath contempt.” Well, America is the epicenter of globalism and the tip of the anti-White spear, constantly selling diversity to Europeans via its Big Tech-driven propaganda machine.

    I admit that Musk can be likeable, but ultimately I think he’s a faker and a state actor who wants us to keep believing in a terrible system.

      • Henry Petersen
        Henry Petersen says:

        I recently bothered to READ Saul Alinsky’s “Rules for Radicals”. Good strategic advice that WN activists on the other side could well follow.

      • StopWhiteGenocide
        StopWhiteGenocide says:

        For starters you need to treat invaders so badly that nobody would think of invading. For example, Italy and Spain could choose to destroy boats carrying Africans. The boats would stop coming.

        In hopelessly diverse places like the USA, you need the ability to segregate. I think a multiracial empire that is partially composed of racially exclusive communities or states could work fine.

        Just a couple of thoughts off the top of my head.

  8. kmacks McDonald
    kmacks McDonald says:

    This black New York Times journalist is sad his little scare tactics no longer work. He fears calling everyone a Nazi or White supremacist, or racist anymore has been tried too many times and now falls on deaf ears. I do wish Musk would do 3 things though.

    1. Use money to help increase White birthrates, buy or pay to build a Mormon temple somewhere, start a right wing matchmaking service, fund IVF treatments and make them less expensive for White couples. Try to reduce plastics for people by providing alternatives.

    2. Donate to Eva Vladingerbroek, Martin Sellnar and their remigration group. Also promote their Save Europe Act petition, that is over 650,000 signatures and needs to get to 1 million.

    3. Donate to America Firs Legal so Anti White discrimination is no longer tolerated. Lawfare abound on corporations and individuals who practice it.

    4. Donate to European parties and politicians who believe in immigration restriction.

    3.

Comments are closed.