“Are You a Philo-Semite?”
1061 Words
We have long passed the point of meaningful political debate in the West. But that does not mean that there is no longer any point to debate. There still is—but only as theater. Only as a meta-influence upon culture. What else could it be when the syllogisms unspooled by all sides basically amount to rhetorical rationalizations for enhancing the power or security of one’s particular tribe? It’s rare to find a pundit of any stripe who does otherwise, who argues against his own personal, tribal interest. It’s natural, yes. But it makes a mockery of logic, philosophy, ethics, and whatever other notions that go into making great civilizations great.
Despite this unfortunate fact, debate can still serve a purpose—which is to influence not the debaters themselves or their committed followers, but those witnessing the debate who have not yet determined their tribal affiliation. And the best way to do this is not to win an argument in a formal sense, but to embarrass one’s opponent into looking stupid.
The ability to embarrass is indeed a form of power because it carries with it the threat to reduce the social status of anyone who dares contradict you in front of others. One way to do this is to force one’s opponent to respond to a line of reasoning which they haven’t yet considered. This takes him out of his comfort zone and forces him to think in the moment, like a chess player refuting home preparation over the board with the clock ticking. Always a risky proposition.
And one way for the Right to do this when arguing politics with the Left is to ask a simple question: “Are you a philo-Semite?”
This will strike the hardest whenever a leftist accuses the Right of fascism. And they do this a lot.
Here is media personality Mehdi Hasan calling Donald Trump a fascist in 2022, 2024, and 2026.
Here is Young Turks co-host Cenk Uygur calling Donald Trump a fascist in 2018, 2023, and 2025.
Here is internet streamer Destiny calling Donald Trump a fascist in 2020, 2023, and 2025.
Here is the New York Times calling Donald Trump a fascist.
Here is the Atlantic calling Donald Trump a fascist.
I could go on. We all know that lefties like to use the F-word to describe prominent figures on the Right—and it doesn’t matter if they understand what fascism truly is or not. This is when they should be told that they resemble a philo-Semite. Why?
Because only a philo-Semite could view fascism in such a negative light. This is the case especially when comparing fascism to Bolshevism.
Both systems are authoritarian, it’s true. But judging from the numbers, the latter murdered far more people during peacetime than the former. This is a documented, undisputed fact. By 1939, the Bolsheviks had been responsible for anywhere between 10 and 20 million deaths, while the Nazis before the war had been responsible for maybe one one-fiftieth of that—one-twenty-fifth on the high end. So slam dunk for the fascists, right? Calling your opponent a fascist while not denouncing Bolshevism is clearly a self-defeating argument.
Well, not so fast. If you believe that Jewish lives are more valuable than non-Jewish lives—like a philo-Semite would—then fascism is indeed worse than Bolshevism. Under fascism—at least the German kind, which is all that matters in these debates—Jews were excluded from mainstream society. Prior to the war, they were to varying degrees discriminated against and oppressed in Germany. Of course, they were treated quite well when compared to the internal enemies of the Soviet regime, but that doesn’t matter if you consider Jews to be inherently more valuable than gentiles.
On the other hand, ethnic Jews were not only not excluded from mainstream Soviet society, they were in fact disproportionately in charge of Soviet society. They were also disproportionately responsible for pre-war atrocities committed by the Soviets. As a result, Bolshevism was better for Jews than fascism was because under Bolshevism Jews wielded more power.
Put simply, if you’re a philo-Semite, fascism must be worse than Bolshevism. If you’re not a philo-Semite, then Bolshevism must be worse than fascism. Only a philo-Semite can be mortally offended by fascism, while looking the other way with regards to Bolshevism. As a result, leftists inadvertently make themselves rhetorically vulnerable whenever they trot out the bugbear of fascism to describe people on the Right they don’t like. They don’t realize how easily the “philo-Semite” charge can be weaponized against them.
All one needs to do ask them if they’re philo-Semitic. There is no easy way to answer, and lefties will risk embarrassment trying. They could cop to it, but that would alienate their base, which is increasingly anti-Semitic thanks to the ongoing war in Gaza and the obvious Jewish control over US Middle East policy. It would also be tantamount to admitting to the inherent superiority of Jews over gentiles—an equally embarrassing position for someone on the Left. Alternatively, they could reject the charge, but that would alienate Jewish leftists who make up the financial backbone of the Democrat Party. It would also open that person up to the counter-charge of anti-Semitism, which, as we all know, can complicate one’s life greatly.
On the flipside, they can claim neutrality. But that doesn’t work given how the numbers are not in favor of the philo-Semites. Soviet peacetime atrocities dwarf those of the Nazis. How can a moral person remain neutral in the face of that? Any leftist who who dares to carp about fascism while pleading neutrality on the Jewish Question needs to be buried under the evidence.
Finally, they could renounce the charge entirely, but this would be a clear act of deflection, which would open a person up to the embarrassing charge of cowardice.
Note also how the Right is insulated from this very tactic as a counter-charge because both the anti-Semitic and Judeo-neutral positions (which I believe constitute the edges of the Overton Window on the Right) are in accordance with Bolshevism being more destructive than fascism.
Thus, when faced with the question, “Are you a philo-Semite?”, lefties will be forced into a very uncomfortable position—either they embarrass themselves trying to answer, or they finally shut up when it comes to calling their political opponents fascists.
Either way, it’s win-win for the Right.





Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!