Dr. Daryl G. Smith’s Imperative for Diversity (Part 2 of 3)
The Q and A
The first questioner noted that at a recent student meeting Whites who advocated an all-inclusive Student Union were “shouted down as being racist. Clearly on campuses across the nation the White European-Americans have been disenfranchised and marginalized to the extent that these are now the students with poor self-esteem, because the system is not inclusive, but exclusive. Whites are denied the right to association and denied the right to be who they are! The pendulum of racism has swung this last century clear from one side to the other without ever centering! The time is now to abandon the childish, well-worn, weaponized words like ‘bigot’ and ‘racist’, and to begin building on communities that can tolerate all the people they live with, including the majority that have been responsible for the unique contributions to the Western Civilization we enjoy.” He went on, quoting from a statement she made earlier about her inclusivity clause: “You stated that there is ‘not a single identity that you wouldn’t stand and fight for’. If that’s the case, then will you help me here today with your administrative connections and expertise in the field in establishing a White student union on this campus?”
This seemed to disorient the professor, and her response seemed to shift from one explanation to another without completing her thoughts. But basically she was saying that you have to consider the structure of the system as a whole. She agreed that not every White person is privileged — “There are a lot of poor [White] folks in the Appalachians. And we should be standing… as a matter of fact if Martin Luther King had not been assassinated, he would have dealt with class issues.”
But she insisted that Whites have a whole host of privileges denied others. “Just as I have a privilege called walking I need to recognize that I have a privilege called Whiteness. I don’t get followed. My son doesn’t get stopped by the police. That doesn’t diminish who I am.”
She also claimed that for Whites to have their own identity groups would be the same as being under “the banner of the Klu Klux Klan.” And the fact is that White people still run the universities. “As you go up [to the higher echelons], look at the faculty, the demographics of most faculties are quite White, and it’s historically White male. Now I’m not going to ban Whites or males … My son is one. But if we don’t begin to understand the histories….” Read more